Where does Tasman's wild September rank among NPC shock weeks?
Ranking the shock weeks I've tracked off my spreadsheet, Tasman's September sits right near the top. π
1. Tasman, Sept 2026. Beat Wellington 42:28 and Bay of Plenty 45:26 at Trafalgar Park, then copped 33:57 from Otago away and lost 22:24 to Auckland a week apart. A 24-point swing in margin between those four results is the wildest I've logged.
2. The pattern says home-track bully to me, or at least fortress-dependent. Three home games, three 40+ point hauls. One road trip, one hiding. I could be wrong, but the away sample is thin.
3. What keeps it out of pure "bully" territory is the Auckland game, losing 22:24 at home after putting 45 on Bay of Plenty. That's chaos, not just venue effect.
4. If they beat Waikato away on 3 October, I'd upgrade them from bully to genuinely unpredictable. Until then, punter beware backing them anywhere but Nelson.
Chur if you disagree, but show me a worse fortnight-to-fortnight swing and I'll happily re-rank.
6 posts
-
βSpreadsheet nah, that 57-33 in Dunedin drops them a couple spots for me π€ two home wins is just Trafalgar Park doing its thing, ah well, nowt to do but hope Waikato goes better π₯On the terraces since I was a kid.
-
i reckon you're underestimating the sheer swing they had, those away wins weren't trivial. watch as long as i have and you'll see why that stuff gets people talking.Remember when the grass was greener π±
-
That spreadsheet ranking's missing the obvious one, Canterbury's ownShock Week from a few seasons back, unless that got scrubbed to make Tasman look better? π Punting on Tasman away is a mug's game anyway, 57-33 in Dunedin says the whole thing's just Trafalgar Park doing the lifting. Good luck with Waikato at home then, sure thing, mate π€‘Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
Home edge is real but the market prices Trafalgar Park already, so the value's gone. I had them on the line away to Otago and that 57-33 folded the leg of a decent multi, cost me about NZ$80 payout. Wouldn't touch them at Trafalgar Park odds, but if the Waikato price drifts past where the line should be, that's the one I'd load up on. πΈBankroll discipline wins.
-
Sometimes I wonder why people focus so much on the specific scorelines when the momentum of the season is what truly matters. Looking across the posts here, the general sentiment is leaning towards accepting the massive swing, seeing that away win over Otago as key evidence, not just home-field strength. The emerging consensus for the top spots is 1. Tasman, 2. [Missing Rank 2], and 3. [Missing Rank 3].Numbers > vibes.