Tasman beat Wellington 42:28 then folded 57:33 to Otago a week later
Which Mako side turns up? The one that lost at home to Auckland by two, that's the one turning up π Hammered Wellington 42:28 then Otago took 57 off us a week later, and suddenly everyone's convinced the Bay of Plenty 45:26 means something. I'd happily put NZ$20 on Waikato at the TAB just to watch the optimists cry. Remind me of your record on these calls? π€‘
6 posts
-
βThe Otago trip says less about the side than Andy wants it to, one bad away day after a short turnaround isn't a personality trait. What I'd want explained is Auckland going down by two at Trafalgar Park, because that's the result nobody in the doom camp can actually account for. If Waikato away on October 3 goes the way of Dunedin I'll happily eat the words, on condition the same standard applies when Bay of Plenty gets repeated.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
45:26 on the Bay of Plenty was no fluke Andy, watched the lads win those collisions everywhere πͺπ₯ Roll on Waikato, get in! πOne love, one side β€οΈ
-
I keep my own table on this lot and the pattern is simpler than Andy wants it. Three of the five matches were competitive or dominant: Wellington put away 42:28, Bay of Plenty beaten 45:26, Auckland only going down 22:24 at Trafalgar Park where a couple of kicks either way flips it. So Millie's right about the collisions against Bay of Plenty, I watched the same thing. The 57:33 in Dunedin is the outlier in the sample, and one heavy away defeat in five data points is a wobble, not a personality. Robbed made the point I'd have made: the home record is the anchor. Two wins plus a two-point loss at Trafalgar Park versus a shambles on the road. Waikato away on 2026-10-03 sits right on the fault line, so I'm not calling it confidently. Caveat as always, five matches is a tiny sample, but if a punter took the Mako at home I'd back them every time, away I'd want the line and a decent price.Numbers > vibes.
-
Saw that Otago scoreline and it took me straight back to the old Carisbrook nights when any side coming south got chewed up, so Andy, dunno if that 57 tells you much about the Makos. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it, one away hiding means nothing. The Bay of Plenty win looked real to me, and I'd take us at Waikato on the third before I'd write them off πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
Iβm looking at the scores across the last few weekends and itβs a mess because everyone is focusing on one single point of data. The performance level isn't binary; it depends entirely on whether you are calculating home defensive metrics or overall seasonal consistency. If you look purely at the metrics surrounding their home games, the picture is much clearer: that win against Wellington (42:28) and the victory over the Bay of Plenty (45:26) show a strong attacking output when they have the support of their own fans. But even that narrow loss to Auckland at Trafalgar Park (22:24) shows vulnerability under pressure, suggesting the unit can crack. Contrast that solid home showing with the away fixture against Otago (33:57), where the team lost badly after a short turnaround. Given these two very distinct patterns, predicting a specific result for the Waikato match remains highly speculative, regardless of how confident we are in the unit's ability to handle the contest.Numbers > vibes.