After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:49 am Log in Sign up

The Highlanders should rebuild around the academy kids and stop

club debate Highlanders Supporters Highlanders 10 posts Β·99 views Β·Posted: 28 Sep 2026, 8:29 am
Highlanders
Funny how the club keep paying marquee money for blokes who last five minutes while the academy kids from Otago Boys' run the show every pre-season 🀑 Stop chasing names and build around the juniors already. Anyone defending another big cheque can remind me of your ROI? 😏
BA BadBeatAndy Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 28 Sep 2026, 8:29 am

10 posts

  • βœ“
    Pre-season run against what, second-string defenders in February? I'll believe the academy lads are the answer when they do it in actual Super Rugby rounds, on condition someone shows me minutes and turnovers, not highlights. Meanwhile the marquee spend stung, sure, but one bad contract doesn't prove youth solves everything. Cute emoji though.
    Sample first, conclusions after.
    RO RobReds Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 28 Sep 2026, 2:47 pm Quote
  • Who's asking for a full Super Rugby rΓ©sumΓ© from teenagers? They get looked at ONCE, have one decent pre-season, and go πŸ’€ Nothing ever changes with these blokes. Give them minutes in real games or stop pretending we care about the academy πŸ’ͺπŸ”₯
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    JO JoshDiehard Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 3:47 am Quote
  • Josh has got a point buried in there, and it's worth pulling apart properly. Rob is right that February footy against second-stringers proves very little, I'd never hang an argument on a pre-season run. But his standard cuts both ways: if the kids only get looked at once and never see real rounds, then of course the sample stays tiny and we keep concluding they're not ready. That's a selection loop, not an evaluation. Caveat on my own numbers here: one marquee centre on big money over a single season is a small sample too, so I won't pretend it settles the ROI question Andy raised. What it does show is the asymmetry, we spent marquee money on a short-lived import while the Otago Boys' lads ran the show for free in that run. Give the academy boys proper minutes across an actual season, tracked properly, and then we'll have a real sample to argue about instead of highlights vs scepticism. Until then nobody, including me πŸ“Š β€” can honestly say which side is right.
    Highlanders game moment
    Numbers > vibes.
    BO BootToBallGuru Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 5:12 am Quote
  • robbies got half a point about february footy, sure, but back in the day the academy was where we found the real gold, and everyone knew it. remember sitting at the old ground watching those otago boys' lads run amok in pre-season and thinking, there's our next decade right there. then the chequebook would come out for some marquee name on big money, he'd pull a hammy by round six and disappear, and the kid who'd earned his spot went back to the bench. seen worse clubs do it, mind you, but we did it enough times to learn. all josh is asking, and i reckon he's right, is give them real minutes before we write them off. a teenager thrown in for twenty minutes against the crusaders learns more than three february highlights reels. patience costs nothing; another fancy signature costs plenty. πŸ˜‰
    Seen it all, trust me.
    FA FanaticTillIDie Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 6:22 am Quote
  • What did that marquee centre actually cost us, again? Because I'd rather back kids who turn up every Tuesday than another cheque that buys six months of injuries.
    Sample first, conclusions after.
    SU Supporter_Zone Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 10:25 am Quote
  • I could be wrong, but Supporter_Zone has hit on the honest question. What did that marquee centre actually cost us before he limped off? I never kept a tidy column for it in my season spreadsheet, mostly because the return column stayed empty. My one caveat: give the Otago Boys' lads real minutes before we crown them, pre-season runs tell you appetite, and that's about it. πŸ“Š
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 2:31 pm Quote
  • Chris, you'd have loved my spreadsheet then, I do keep a column for it, and the return column stayed emptier than Forsyth Barr on a wet Friday. Small sample though, one marquee signing doesn't damn the whole transfer policy, the way one good pre-season run doesn't canonise the Otago Boys' lads either. There's a nuance here: the academy kids showed us seven weeks of footy; the cheque showed us six months of physio rooms. Neither is a decade of evidence. Where I'd leave it: the question Supporter_Zone asked is the right one, and nobody's answered it yet with a number. Until someone can tell me what that centre actually cost us against what an academy graduate costs in development dollars, both sides are arguing taste rather than maths. I'm not closing the books on this one. πŸ“Š
    Highlanders team
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 29 Sep 2026, 5:48 pm Quote
  • ChrisDiehard387 wrote:
    I could be wrong, but Supporter_Zone has hit on the honest question. What did that marquee centre actually cost us before he limped off? I never kept a tidy column for it in my season spreadsheet, mostly because the retu…
    @ChrisDiehard387 return column stayed empty alright 😱 forget spreadsheets, just back the academy kids through thick and thin... they can't be worse 🀬πŸ’ͺ
    One love, one side ❀️
    FU FullbackNut Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 28 Oct 2026, 10:47 am Quote
  • @FullbackNut spot on πŸ”₯ coached plenty of those juniors meself, they run harder than any bloke we flew in. Give 'em proper game time and watch πŸ”΄
    OL OldSchool_SinceDayOne2012 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† 10 Nov 2026, 4:23 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up β€” it's quick.