Tasman's defence is fine, the 57-point Otago night was just a bad blip
Took the Otago game off myself, was over in Nelson that Friday anyway, and even I couldn't stomach paying to watch that. But one stinker doesn't kill a system, does it. Same defence held Wellington to 28 at Trafalgar Park and beat them by 14, then put 45 on Bay of Plenty a fortnight later. Auckland was 22:24, one score. You don't scrap a whole structure over one night in Dunedin where everything bounced the wrong way.
And in reality? The Mako going to Hamilton on 3 October and grinding out a result against Waikato ends this chat real quick. Half of you lot had them written off after Otago and were probably burning your TAB slip that same evening. If they turn up sweet as down south and win, the 57 becomes a footnote. If they fold again, fair enough, I'll wear the egg on my face. Till then I'm backing the system 😏
6 posts
-
✓Took the Otago game off myself, was over in Nelson that Friday anyway, and even I couldn't stomach paying to watch that. But one stinker doesn't kill a system, does it. Same defence held Wellington to 28 at Trafalgar Par…One blip, sure, but Otago ran 57 past you and that's not a rounding error. Wellington at 28 and Bay of Plenty at 26 were both home games at Trafalgar Park, so the "system works" claim is built entirely on home fixtures plus a one-score loss to Auckland. Waikato away on 3 October is the first actual test, and I'd want to see it before anyone declares the Otago game weather.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Nah RobbedAgain you can't just wipe the Wellington and Bay of Plenty wins cos they were at Trafalgar 😤 we put 45 and 42 on the board, defence held when it mattered. One horror night in Dunedin doesn't kill the system, we go down to Waikato on 3 October and grind out a result, the Otago game becomes a footnote. Backing them all day 🖤💛Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
I could be wrong, but RobbedAgain has a point buried in there. The two wins came at Trafalgar Park where the Mako look comfortable, and the road sample we've got is the 57-point mess in Dunedin plus a one-score loss to Auckland. Small sample though, so one away result at Waikato on 3 October tells us more about the defence than all the home fixtures combined. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Every side's had a Dunedin-shaped hole in its season, I've watched enough winter nights to know that. Back in the day the great teams still got turned over once and nobody wrote the whole thing off. Road test at Waikato on 3 October will tell us more than any of the Trafalgar wins, and I'd back this lot to grind it out 😉Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
DannyFaithful's framing is the fairest read so far, and I'd add one caveat: four matches is a tiny sample, so I wouldn't die on either hill yet. The nuance is that the two convincing wins came against Wellington and Bay of Plenty at Trafalgar Park, where travel fatigue and crowd count for something, while the only genuine road test was Dunedin, and Dunedin went badly. Auckland away isn't road anyway, half that crowd treats it like a home fixture, same reason tests at Eden Park feel different. So the honest position is this: nobody's proved the system travels, and nobody's proved it doesn't. If the Mako hold Waikato to something manageable in Hamilton on 3 October, the Otago night shrinks to an outlier with a plausible story. If they ship 40-plus again, RobbedAgain gets his answer twice over. I'll be keeping my own running table through that one before I call it 📊