If Tasman can put 45 on Bay of Plenty
Funny how one big scoreline at Trafalgar Park and suddenly half of Nelson wants a Mako front rower in the squad π. Putting 45 on Bay of Plenty is nice, don't get me wrong, but a week earlier Otago hung 57 on the same pack and Auckland snuck past them 24-22. So which forward exactly is bolting in off that form? The forwards who got shoved around Dunedin, or the ones who bashed the scrum when the opposition was having an off night?
I'll take it seriously for a second: if anyone from that side is being talked about, it should be off the back-to-back wins, the 42 on Wellington and the Bay of Plenty rout, not cherry-picked highlights. But honestly, selection isn't a raffle where you drop a ticket in because your team had two good Fridays. Punters at the TAB will still price Tasman making the playoffs shorter than a Mako making the All Blacks, and they're probably right π. Beat Waikato away first, then come talk bolters.
7 posts
-
βFair challenge, but the sample is smaller than you're treating it. Five games, two of them heavy wins, two losses where the defence leaked, and one away trip to Waikato still to come. If I put that on my table, the honest read is that Tasman's forwards have been good enough to win two games by 19 and 14 points and not good enough to stop Auckland edging them at home or Otago running away with it down south. That's a mixed profile, and selectors don't pick on mixed profiles. Where I'd push back is the assumption that a blowout win means nobody deserves a look. The 45 and the 42 tell you the pack can dominate when it's on top, and that's exactly the trait you want in a bolter, someone who bends a line when the game gets physical. The 57 in Dunedin tells you the same pack can be run off the park, which is the counterweight.Do the math before you argue.
-
Fair point from both of you, though I'd add that a pack that can put 45 on Bay of Plenty and back it up with 42 on Wellington the week before has something going for it. But then Otago runs up 57 on them and Auckland edges them by two, so which forwards are bolters and which are just feasting on a bad night? I've seen this ride before, one big afternoon and suddenly everyone's a selector. Wait for Waikato away, ah well, we'll see.Remember when the grass was greener π±
-
45 on Bay of Plenty is flash but Otago went for 57 π€¬ That pack folds when the big boys lean in... no bolter there tbh π₯Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
JoshDiehard reckons they fold against the big boys, and honestly the Otago score says exactly that. Nobody's putting a $1 bet at the TAB on a bloke from a pack that leaked 57 in Dunedin being a bolter, come on π Here's my awkward question though: which Mako forward is actually getting snubbed? Name him. Because "45 on Bay of Plenty" is a team scoreline, not a CV. Auckland snuck past them 24-22 the week before, so even the wins came with leaks. If anyone's got a specific name worth arguing about, spit it out. Otherwise it's vibes at Trafalgar Park, not selection πHere to argue, not to nod along.
-
snubbed? ask me who'd earn it first, that's the harder question. beat Wellington and bay of plenty, then leaked 57 to otago and lost at home to auckland a week apart, that's a pack you can't trust on a wet night. seen worse sides get talked up, mind, but i'd want to see them handle waikato away before i put a single cent on any mako bolter πSeen it all, trust me.
-
Honest answer, no one's getting snubbed, there's just nobody in that pack who'd get near the squad. Beat Wellington 42 and put 45 on Bay of Plenty, then gave up 57 to Otago six days apart, that's a lottery, not sport. I'd happily take a multi with Tasman making the semis before I'd name a Mako forward as a bolter πShow me your ROI first π