Honestly, the 2015 Highlanders side would hammer this current mob
Change your mind? Mate, I'd want better odds than a TAB multi to back this current mob against the 2015 boys π
Fifteen in his prime alone tips it, but roll out the midfield pick anyway: Sopoaga at 10 with that boot and running game, Fekitoa at 12 smashing anything that moves, and I'd slot Fekitoa's mate whatever you like at 13 because half our current backs would struggle to get a bench spot in that squad. Am I being harsh? Sure thing. But some of you lot rate this year's playmakers like they've already got a title tucked away. Remind me of your ROI on that confidence? π€‘πΈ
Drop your 10-12-13 and I'll happily tell you why you're wrong.
6 posts
-
βComparing a title-winning side to one that hasn't proven anything yet seems generous, Rob. Sopoaga's boot was real, no argument there, but Fekitoa at 12? He spent most of 2015 making highlight reels and conceding penalties in equal measure. Malakai Fekitoa defending at inside centre against a proper rushing attack is where that pick falls over. I'd have you on one condition though: if the current playmakers actually string together six straight weeks of clean service and a functioning kicking game, maybe the gap closes. Until they show me that, I'm not picking any current backline over Sopoaga-Lima-Naholo with a straight face. Fifteen in his prime alone probably sells more tickets than the whole current season. Prove me wrong, fellas.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Nah Rob's onto something here π€ Fekitoa conceding penalties? every midfield does, at least his hits got the crowd up at the house of pain. 2015 lifted the trophy for a reason fellas, I was there and I still get chills π Get in!One love, one side β€οΈ
-
RobbedAgain has a point buried in there, even if he buried it too deep. I keep a running tally of midfield penalties every season and Fekitoa's 2015 was uglier than the memory of it. The hits were real, the rift tackles got the crowd up, but he gave away soft ones at the breakdown week after week. Small sample though, one campaign, so I'd caution anyone treating it as a full career verdict. My pick at 10-12-13 for the dream matchup: Sopoaga at 10, no debate, that boot controlled territory better than anything we've had since. Fekitoa at 12 with a licence to run and a kick-cam watching his discipline. And at 13 I'd want someone who could actually hold the defensive line, because Rob's side wins the highlight reel and loses the penalty count. That's the nuance with the 2015 mob, they weren't just flash, they strangled derbies at Forsyth Barr through territory and turnover. Current playmakers haven't proven they can do that for eighty minutes yet. π
-
Back in my day we used to judge a midfielder by how he backed up the next week, not by one big hit on the telly. Fekitoa could flatten you Saturday then get pinged soft five minutes later, both true. Young Fellas today have better skills across the park but that 2015 pack made ten and twelve look like kings πRemember when the grass was greener π±
-
Both things can be true lads: Fekitoa's 2015 was messy on the whistle and still the best midfield we've had. Sample of one season each, mind, so I'm keeping my pick 10-12-13 to myself till someone changes it πNumbers > vibes.