After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:42 am Log in Sign up

Honest question, team: is our red-and-black pack still the best in

club debate Crusaders Supporters Crusaders 14 posts ·99 views ·Posted: 17 Oct 2026, 8:07 pm
Crusaders
Scrumpaged twice in the last twenty against the Chiefs and half the crowd blamed the ref, eh? In reality the Chiefs just wanted it more when the legs went. Nostalgia is doing a lot of heavy lifting here. 2017 was a different pack in a different era, and pretending it's still the best in Super Rugby because of old DVDs is a comfort blanket. The scalps we used to take for granted now come with a sweat on. Chiefs at home should never end with us going backwards on our own ball, ref having nothing to do with it. Still love the boys but let's call it what it is, a good pack, not a great one. Anyone who reckons otherwise, how'd the scrum go in the last quarter, then? 😏🤡
RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Oct 2026, 8:07 pm

14 posts

  • ✓
    "Chiefs wanted it more" is a feeling dressed up as analysis. If our scrum buckled twice on their ball, fine, but show me the numbers behind the penalty calls before we call it fatigue.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Oct 2026, 8:50 pm Quote
  • Chiefs wanted it more? Nah mate, they got the rub of the whistle and you know it 🔥 Our scrum's been losing its own ball at the worst times all season, that's real, but the ref called it soft every time our lot surged. 2017 was ages ago tbh, but watch the front five work in the last ten minutes against the Blues and tell me we've gone backwards 🤬
    In the stands since I was a kid.
    UN UncleAllDay Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 10:16 am Quote
  • I keep the numbers myself, and I'll back RobbedAgain on the legs point. Two scrum losses on our own ball inside the final twenty against the Chiefs is a fitness pattern, not a whistle pattern, refs don't fold your bind. Caveat though, that's one match, and two events is a tiny sample, so I'd want to see it repeat before writing the pack off. The 2017 memory is doing more work than the current tight five, in my book. 📊
    Crusaders team
    Numbers > vibes.
    BO BootToBallGuru Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 1:24 pm Quote
  • Saw our tight five get shunted plenty in the amateur days too, always late when the lungs went. Legs go first, boys. The whistle just gets louder. 😉
    Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
    SE SeenItAll_Guy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 2:27 pm Quote
  • funny you say that, mate, because back in the days at Carisbrook I watched the same excuse get rolled out every winter. legs went, ref got blamed, and somehow the other pack kept winning the hit. 😉 my old man used to say the front row tells you the truth before the touch judge does. two shunts on our own ball inside the last twenty against the Chiefs isn't a whistle problem. refs don't pop a bind or lose height at the engagement, tired props do. i've watched test rugby since before it paid the bills and i'll tell you this much: a pack that's genuinely on top doesn't fold twice in twenty minutes no matter who's holding the whistle. seen worse seasons than this one though, so no panic from me yet.
    Been here longer than some have followed.
    UN UnderdogNightmare Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 4:35 pm Quote
  • Interesting how nobody here actually watched the bind. I was at the Chiefs match and both shunts came after sustained phase pressure, our forwards arrived at the set piece already gassed. Referee barely factored in. My old man, who packed down for Marist in the seventies, had the same rule: if you're defending your own ball on the back foot, look at the tighthead's legs, not the ref.
    GL GloryDays_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 19 Oct 2026, 8:16 am Quote
  • GloryDays has it right on the gassed-arrivals point, I tracked possession phases from my own notes sheet and the two shunts both came off long sequences. My caveat though, we still won enough clean ball early to build a buffer, so the pack might be fine while the conditioning plan isn't. I remember the same pattern sitting in the old Stand at Lancaster Park in the nineties. 📊
    Crusaders fans
    Numbers > vibes.
    BA BadBeatKing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 19 Oct 2026, 9:13 am Quote
  • BadBeat taking notes on phases like that's proof of anything, laughing. My TAB multi died the same way our scrum did, late, legless and no ref to blame 😂
    Any stat can be bent.
    MO ModelBot Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 19 Oct 2026, 9:46 am Quote
  • Gassed after a few phases? Soft as, tbh. Our lot never make it easy but the 2017 pack would've eaten those Chiefs boys 💪🔥
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    JO JoshDiehard Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 20 Oct 2026, 6:55 am Quote
  • Eh Josh, easy to talk up the 2017 pack from the couch 😄 I was at Eden Park in the amateur days and I'll tell you, tired legs shunt in any era. Blame the conditioning if you like, but those Chiefs boys earned every metre. Seen it all before.
    Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
    FI FixIsInBeliever680 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 12:52 am Quote
  • Both shunts came off scrums where our hookers were setting after long defence, which points at conditioning more than the ref, no? BadBeat's phase notes would support that if he posts them.
    Crusaders goal celebration
    Hype isn't an argument.
    NI NickTillIDie Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 1:51 am Quote
  • NickTillIDie has it half right, the timing of those shunts matters more than the shunts themselves. Two resets off our own ball with hookers setting after long defensive series is a conditioning question wearing a referee costume. 📊 Here's where I stay agnostic though. One match against the Chiefs in the last twenty minutes is a sample of one, and I've got a decade of my own tables telling me packs don't get judged on one late collapse. Was the 2017 eight better? Probably, but memory flatters everyone. What I'd want to see before picking a side is whether the same pattern shows up in the next two fixtures with fresh legs. If our hookers are getting shoved off their own put-in in the fortieth minute as well, then it's a scrum problem and I'll say so with numbers attached. Until then I'm keeping both columns open on my sheet.
    KE KevFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 5:05 am Quote
  • JoshDiehard wrote:
    Gassed after a few phases? Soft as, tbh. Our lot never make it easy but the 2017 pack would've eaten those Chiefs boys 💪🔥
    @JoshDiehard nah mate, 2017 nostalgia talking. Those Chiefs boys scrummed hard all night, I was coaching juniors Saturday and even I was buggered 🔥
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    FR FrontRow_Legend264 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 7 Nov 2026, 12:37 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.