Forget the trophies talk - our best-ever Highlanders backline would
Aaron Smith over anyone at 9, sure, but the whole best-ever backline chat is a joke if you're picking names from the trophy years alone π€‘. Half of you would put Sopoaga in there on one good season and I've watched lads put NZ$20 multis on that logic at the TAB every Friday. 2015 pack wins this argument before kickoff, sure thing, mate π.
6 posts
-
βHalf of those TAB multis come unstuck by Saturday night anyway, so I'd hardly hold them up as a standard of judgement. And I'd argue the opposite problem: too many of you pick on highlight reels, not trophy years. One good season and a player's in the all-time XV, which is exactly the lazy logic I thought you'd be against. So define what "best-ever" actually means before we argue. Peak form or career body of work in a Highlanders jersey? Because if it's careers, Aaron Smith walks in at 9 on sheer volume of games and consistency, and I'd want names in writing for anyone you're putting ahead of him in the rest of the backline. I'll wait.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
Ben Smith at fullback every day, he's the only one we never once worried about π€ Aaron and BB through the halves, done. π₯In the stands since I was a kid.
-
UncleAllDay, I'm with you on Ben Smith, the man just never had a bad month, let alone a bad season, and that consistency is exactly what you can't quantify with a highlight reel. Aaron Smith at 9 is the one pick I'd defend to the death too, service speed like his doesn't come around twice. Rest of the XV I'd dig a bit deeper than the trophy years before naming names though. πDo the math before you argue.
-
Funny how everyone forgets the old days the moment a highlights clip starts rolling π Back in my day we were watching Jeff Wilson lace them up out of Dunedin with no super returns and freezing arse stands, and he'd walk into this backline ahead of plenty of names thrown round here. Big Ben Smith though, yeah, hard to argue, the bloke never let us down once. Ah well, we'll see who else gets a run.Remember when the grass was greener π±
-
Itβs always fun reading through these threads because you see such a huge difference between relying on the big moments and looking at the season-long consistency, mean. Aaron's ability to manage game pace and his delivery under pressure is undeniably elite, but I wonder if that kind of statistical ceiling can truly overcome the sheer physical grind of those legacy defenders. I reckon we're all arguing about two very different definitions of what makes a great team, which is probably the only fair way to look at it.Numbers > vibes.