Counties Manukau at Navigation Homes Stadium: fortress or fraud?
Honest question, which Counties Manukau side turns up at Navigation Homes on 3 October? The one that put 47 on Southland at home, or the mob that copped 50 from Otago on the same turf a fortnight later? Can't be the ground that's the problem if they've done both there 😱
They edged Northland away 22-19 and got shown up by Auckland 43-33, so there's no away masterclass hiding either. Hawke's Bay coming to Pukekohe and tbh I genuinely can't pick it. Fortress or fraud, lads? 🤔
7 posts
-
✓Funny enough I had both games in my spreadsheet within a fortnight of each other and still can't fully explain the swing. Verdict: on form, Counties Manukau at home are stronger than Hawke's Bay on the season's evidence, a 47:24 over Southland beating anything the Magpies have shown here. The wrinkle is the same turf copped 50 from Otago, so the role changes completely depending on which pack fronts up, and the 21:50 loss shows what happens when they get muscled at their own ground. I'd back them on 3 October, small sample though.Numbers > vibes.
-
Honest question, which Counties Manukau side turns up at Navigation Homes on 3 October? The one that put 47 on Southland at home, or the mob that copped 50 from Otago on the same turf a fortnight later? Can't be the grou…50 put on them at home a fortnight after 47 and your spreadsheet still says fortress? 😂 That swing screams lottery, not form. Same turf, Otago proved anyone can rock up. 🤡Any stat can be bent.
-
Spreadsheet says stronger than Hawke's Bay, sure, but one good win over Southland doesn't make a fortress when Otago shipped 50 through them on the same ground. Four games, two decent halves of rugby each. Source on the Magpies being worse? Until someone shows consistency across more than a fortnight, I'd take the 21:50 as the truer sample.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
I was at Carisbrook the night a southern side got 50 hung on them and turned around and won their next two, so a fortnight doesn't worry me much. Seen worse, and I've seen better sides than this Counties Manukau mob do the same thing. Pukekohe was never a true fortress back in my day either, it just suited certain styles. Otago ran them ragged that night, Southland sat off them, simple as that. Over a full season what decides it is the pack and whether they front up every week, and four games is too small a sample for anyone to crow about. That said, edging Northland away by three when you're wobbling tells you something about character. Hawke's Bay on 3 October, I'd back the home side by a whisker, but a punter putting money on either version showing up is having a guess like the rest of us 😉Been here longer than some have followed.
-
50 in a fortnight after 47, that's just a young side playing to the crowd tbh 😤 I'll back them off that Northland grind, 22:19 away says the ticker's there 💪Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
Reading the thread, most lean towards the home side edging Hawke's Bay on 3 October, because the Northland grind shows the ticker and Pukekohe can still produce that Southland half. For the doubters, the Otago 50 on the same turf is the counter, four games is a thin sample and a young side playing to the crowd is a coin toss. My tables say wait on the team sheet before any punter touches the line.Do the math before you argue.