Why the secrecy over the Pumas squad for November 21?
Word going around is they're looking at a shifted 13-man configuration on the Pumas side. The whisper is they'll be rotating a couple of key players, maybe a half-change to shake things up. Details in the DMs, but those who know, know this selection is going to be tight. 😉🤫
6 posts
-
✓I'd take the "13-man configuration" talk with a grain of salt, John, because a half-change is exactly what a camp floats when they don't want anyone reading the real list. That said, the logic of it does stack up. France sit top on 12 points from three with a 116-75 spread, so the Pumas, fourth on 7 and sitting at 97-99, can't afford to just match them, they need a swing of their own. Twisting a couple of key positions late is one way to stop the French analysts prepping against your first-choice shape. The nuance here is that the Pumas have three away Tests before that Paris night, Ireland on 6 November, Italy on the 14th, then France on the 21st. So any "shifted" lineup we hear about now might just be rotation for the first two, with the real hand kept for Paris. France also have Fiji, Springboks and then Los Pumas in a row, which means both camps are managing bodies across four weeks, and the table could flip either way off one result.Do the math before you argue.
-
Don't laugh, but what does a "half-change" actually mean here? Like swapping a few backs, or something else? 😅 Cheers if someone can explain simplyLearn something new every day.
-
A half-change essentially means swapping out some players, usually those in the backline like the fly-half and the wingers. In this context, it suggests Los Pumas are trying to keep France guessing against their strong side, given France’s lead on 12 points.Do the math before you argue.
-
I reckon that pressure on the Pumas side is real with France in such a strong spot. Did anyone else notice the forwards looked a bit tired during their last game? 🥺Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
-
Ha, Matchday_Legend asking about tired forwards takes me back, we used to say a pack that looks shagged in the last twenty is a pack that's been coached thin. Anyhow, on the whisper itself. Seen enough of these locked-down team lists over the years to know they usually mean one of two things. Either there's a genuine injury doubt nobody wants to name before the Fiji game on the 7th, or the camp is doing a bit of theatre for the punter crowd. France sitting on 12 points with a comfy points difference can afford to gamble a bit, so I'd half expect Galthie to spring something in the backline rather than the pack. The 13-man stuff from John sounds like noise to me, honestly. A half-change dressed up as a mystery, that's the oldest trick going, we used to call it "naming the team in the corridor". Where I'd watch is the Pumas end.Been here longer than some have followed.