Forget the imports - our backline only fires when it's built from
Saw someone on here last week raving about another import signing and I nearly spat my coffee out. Tony Brown built that 2015 title off Dunedin club footy, blokes like Nasi Manu who bled for the jersey, and we're back to shopping offshore like the proven formula never happened. Laughable really.
Go on, tell me the draft and club pathways are dead, I'll wait for the fanboys to pile in with their "professional era" excuses. I put NZ$50 on us making the semis every year off local lads alone and it's the same story, one hot month then a limp exit. The club-to-super pathway made us feared once. Would rather watch a Faddes-type local bust his gut than another mercenary passing through on his way to Japan. 🤡
7 posts
-
✓Saw someone on here last week raving about another import signing and I nearly spat my coffee out. Tony Brown built that 2015 title off Dunedin club footy, blokes like Nasi Manu who bled for the jersey, and we're back to…Nasi Manu came through Otago club footy, sure, but so did plenty of blokes who never got near a Super Rugby title run. One fairytale season isn't a recruitment policy, and Brown also had those All Black midfielders you're conveniently not counting. Where exactly does the club product end and the rest of the roster start in your version of 2015?
-
Nah GloryDays you can't write off 2015 like that 😤 I was at the semifinal, whole ground singing, half that side came up through the Dunedin clubs and you could FEEL it. Local lads play with heart, imports just play for the pay cheque ah well, nowt to do 🔥💪On the terraces since I was a kid.
-
GloryDays has half a point, one title run is a small sample though. I keep my own tables and the pattern from that season holds up: the locally developed forwards carried the workload so the ABs midfield could finish. So both things were true at once, and a squad needs the blend. Caving in and shopping offshore every time a season wobbles is the bit that gets me. 📊
-
watched the 2015 run from my couch in Dunedin after years of standing on the terraces at the old ground, and I'll tell you what stuck with me. it wasn't just the midfield class, it was that the pack and the loosies around Manu felt like they'd grown up five streets from each other. you could see it in the way they scrambled for each other. FixIsIn has it about right though, the blend is the point. Brown had the All Black stars to finish things, but he needed those club-hardened locals to do the dirty work, and he knew where to find them. seen worse recruitment policies than starting at your own doorstep 😄 I'd just like the current mob to remember that before they sign the next big-money name from offshore.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
You could really see the Dunedin club feel bleeding into their game during the title run. That kind of local connection is what matters.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Read the whole thread with a coffee going and I keep coming back to the same wobble in my own thinking. My tables only go back so far, and one title run is a thin sample for a grand theory. FixIsIn has the shape of it right I reckon: the locally grown forwards did the grunt work in 2015 and the classy midfield finished it off. Both halves mattered. So the honest question for me is what we're actually optimising for. If an import blocks a Taieri or Southern product from getting ten games of Super rugby at 22, that cost never shows up on the season's table, it shows up three years later. If the import is clearly better right now, well, the ladder doesn't wait. I can't settle that from a spreadsheet, and anyone who says they can is overselling it. Curious where the club-first crowd draws the line though.Do the math before you argue.