What is a penalty kick in simple terms?
Can someone explain simply what a penalty kick actually is? Don't laugh π
I've been watching games with my flatmates and every time the ref blows for a penalty the team does something different, sometimes they kick at goal, sometimes they boot it way down the line, and sometimes the halfback just taps it and runs and everyone yells.
Like, why don't they always just take the easy shot at the posts? I saw a tap one near the line the other week and honestly thought the bloke had made a mistake until they scored off it lol. Is there a rule for when each option is allowed or is it just whatever the captain reckons at the time? π
8 posts
-
βNo laugh here mate, good question. Half the blokes at the club bar can't answer it either π So when the ref blows for a penalty, the non-offending team holds the options: have a shot at goal for three points, kick for touch and get a lineout deep in enemy territory, take a quick tap and go, or scrum. That's the whole menu. Which one they pick depends on where they are on the park - close to the posts they'll usually have a crack at goal, in the corner they'll point to the line and set up the lineout drive, and if they smell a tiring defence they'll tap and run before anyone can set the wall. Back in my day there was none of this tap-and-go chicanery, you planted the mark and the halfback dived in like a startled rabbit, but the principle's the same. Watch a Ranfurly Shield challenge and you'll see the skipper weighing it up like a punter at the TAB. Points on the board or territory? A soft old saying for it: a bird in the hand beats two in the bush.Remember when the grass was greener π±
-
This helped heaps, cheers π But what if the tap-and-go gets stopped straight away. Do you lose the penalty chance for good, or can you still take the three?
-
-
Watch what the captain actually does and you'll see the logic instantly. Say the penalty lands 40 metres out, tight near the touchline - even a goal kicker of Beauden Barrett's quality is turning that down more often than not, so the skipper points to touch and takes the lineout five metres out instead. Same penalty, but conceded right in front of the posts with a gentle breeze? Straight at the sticks, three points banked. And when it's late in the test, your side is chasing the game and you need tries rather than three-pointers, the tap-and-go becomes the call - think of all those All Blacks quick taps near the line where the defence is still organising. The options don't change, the situation does. There's a nuance here though: a "shot at goal" only becomes realistic once you're inside range, so if the penalty comes on halfway you'll almost always see touch or a tap, never the kick.
-
Watch what the captain actually does and you'll see the logic instantly. Say the penalty lands 40 metres out, tight near the touchline - even a goal kicker of Beauden Barrett's quality is turning that down more often thaβ¦@FixIsInPTSD this is spot on tbh, the angle near the touchline makes it a monster kick even for someone like Beauden πͺ I remember coaching the juniors and telling them exactly this, watch the skipper's eyes before the whistle blows, he's already made the call π our lot never make it easy but the good captains just know when five metres out and a driving lineout beats three points every time π₯You don't abandon your own.
-
right answer from paul there, once you tap, that's it. in short: the penalty gives you one choice, shot at goal, kick to touch, or tap and run. And it's spent the moment you take it.πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
Observing a player's eyes is a standard observation, but does that truly define the tactical mechanics of a penalty kick? One would think we'd find more reliable data regarding the wind speed or the turf's condition being the deciding factors, rather than personal intuition about the kicker's state.