How does the scrum actually work when the ref calls it for a knock-on?
Hi all, I watched a Mitre 10 Cup game at the weekend and got properly lost when the ref blew for a knock-on and everyone packed down π
Maybe I'm wrong, but I still don't get how a scrum actually works? Like who puts the ball in, and how do they decide which side gets the feed after a knock-on? Thanks in advance π
8 posts
-
βGood on you for asking rather than nodding along like half the young lot do. Simple version: when someone knocks the ball forward or throws a pass that drifts ahead of them, the ref blows it up and the scrum is how play restarts. The team that didn't do the infringement gets to feed the ball into the tunnel between the two packs, which is a fair old advantage on its own. The eight forwards from each side bind up, crouch, then the hooker in the middle front row strikes the ball back with his feet once it comes in, while everyone behind pushes to keep the platform steady. Winning it usually comes down to which front row is stronger and whether the hooker gets his boot on the ball first, and the ref watches for early shoving or collapses before he'll let anything go. Back in the day at Eden Park you could stand right by the tunnel and hear the packs crunch together, lovely sound. Watch as long as I have and you'll start picking the hit before the ref does πWatch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Okay so the team without the knock-on puts it in, got it now π But what if both sides fumble at once, who feeds then? Don't laugh, guys πNew here, soaking it up.
-
Okay so the team without the knock-on puts it in, got it now π But what if both sides fumble at once, who feeds then? Don't laugh, guys π@Josh_Auckland nobody's laughing mate, we all were that newbie once π GloryDays already got you covered, forward team feeds it. My advice, just yell "whose ball ref" from the couch, works every time π€£Only serious one here β barely.
-
Josh, when the ref can't tell whose fault it was, the feed goes to the team that was going forward before the stoppage. Source: World Rugby Law 15.
-
Right, the feed question trips everyone up at first. Think of it this way: the team that did NOT knock it on gets to put the ball in. So if a North Harbour winger fumbles a pass forward, Tasman get the feed. The halfback from that team then rolls the ball into the tunnel between the two front rows, and his hooker tries to strike it back with a foot while both packs push. Now here's a nuance people miss: having the feed is a big edge but not a guarantee. The put-in goes in on your side, so your hooker gets first touch, yet if the other eight shove better and drive you off the ball, they can still pinch it. Watch a Bledisloe Test sometime and count how many All Black scrums get turned over despite the Wallabies feeding. Small sample warning though, a single game of scrum penalties tells you very little about who actually has the stronger pack across a season πNumbers > vibes.
-
No laugh from me Josh, we all started there. In short: after a knock-on or forward pass the ref awards a scrum, the non-offending team feeds the ball in through the middle, the packs push to win it, and if nobody's sure who erred, the team moving forward gets the put-in. Back in the day the hooking was a genuine craft, ah well, we'll see how the young fellas go with it.Seen it all, lads.
-
Right, the feed question trips everyone up at first. Think of it this way: the team that did NOT knock it on gets to put the ball in. So if a North Harbour winger fumbles a pass forward, Tasman get the feed. The halfbackβ¦It strikes me as simplistic to say the non-offending team simply 'gets the feed' when the flow of the game really dictates the mechanics of the scrum. While it is technically true that if North Harbour commits a knock-on, the attacking line from Tasman must feed through the middle to restart play, the actual pressure in that situation is huge. The feeding team isn't just putting a ball in; they are essentially resetting the phase after a mistake, and the receiving side often has a slight numerical or positional advantage depending on where the knock-on occurred in the breakdown. I've seen matches where even if the call is dead, the momentum is so established that the fault becomes secondary to the immediate tactical disadvantage of having to regather under pressure, which is something the officials always have to account for when awarding the put-in.Numbers > vibes.