North Harbour should stop chasing big-name signings and build purely
Another season, another thread begging for a marquee name to bail us out π€‘ Face it, the imports we've borrowed over the years have come and gone like travellers through a transit lounge, and where's the silverware? Gone quiet, hasn't it. Give me the kid from our own Albany academy at 10, mistakes and all, for three seasons. At least he'll know what the jersey means when North Harbour Stadium is roaring. Everyone quick to remind me I'm dreaming, sure thing, mate, but what's the plan otherwise, rent another franchise's leftΒover 10 and finish seventh again? π
12 posts
-
βAnother season, another thread begging for a marquee name to bail us out π€‘ Face it, the imports we've borrowed over the years have come and gone like travellers through a transit lounge, and where's the silverware? Gone β¦Three seasons of deliberate losing so we can feel pure about it? I'd want to see one example of that actually working before I sign off on the plan. Clubs rebuild all the time, but "build purely from Albany juniors" is doing a lot of heavy lifting. Our academy hasn't exactly been pumping out NPC-ready tens lately, and a 20-year-old handed the number 10 jersey against a full-strength province gets eaten alive. Nothing wrong with blooding the kid off the bench in winnable patches, but that's different from torching three years of results on principle. And Rob, "imports have come and gone like travellers". Fine, but where's the data that homegrown sides here performed better? Feels more like a vibe than a plan. Gut feeling dressed up as development policy. If the academy kid is genuinely the best option, pick him on merit. If he's not, no amount of sentiment at North Harbour Stadium wins you the Bledisloe-era-standard rugby we all want to watch. Not convinced yet. Source on any of it?
-
GloryDays, our lot never make it easy. But I coached half these Albany kids on Saturday mornings, and you just know they'd die for that jersey π₯ Imports pull on the shirt, locals grow up bleeding for it. Three lean seasons? Give me that over another transit-lounge mercenary at 10 tbh πͺπHeart with the team, head on pause.
-
GloryDays, Canterbury bled through the late 2010s before reloading - the patience pays. I'd back an Albany kid at 10 who knows our patterns over another mercenary import.Numbers > vibes.
-
FrontRow, you've got it spot on about the kids bleeding for the jersey. Seen worse Harbour sides than a young one learning on the job, believe me π Back in the amateur days half our best years came from lads who grew up down the road, and nobody minded a few losses when you could see them getting better each week. Give the Albany kid the 10 and let him grow into it.Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
BadBeatKing has the right of it, I reckon, an Albany kid at 10 who's run our patterns since he was at school beats a mercenary on paper every time. Only caveat from me: patience has to be real, because I keep a little spreadsheet of academy minutes each season and our graduates have never had a proper run when an import is parked in front of them π Could be wrong, but give the kid six straight starts before we judge him.Do the math before you argue.
-
I'd put a lazy tenner at the TAB on the academy kid outplaying any import you chuck in there. Imports cost plenty and deliver sweet FA πIt's a lottery, not sport.
-
Sry lads but a spreadsheet of academy minutes? π that proves nothing, our young 10 could get eaten alive v Canterbury in round 1. Through thick and thin, sure, but three seasons of pain... ah well, nowt to do, I'm half in π₯You don't abandon your own.
-
fair enough faith, three seasons of pain is a big ask π but i watched a raw young fella get chewed up by canterbury decades back and he ended up wearing the black jersey, you can't shortcut that learning. give the albany kid the 10 jersey, keep the import on the bench as cover, and back your own for once. seen worse harbour sides than a green one having a go πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
SeenItAllFaithful's Canterbury worry is fair, I could be wrong, but Underdog's point is the counterweight that matters, the chewed-up kid who ended up in the black jersey didn't learn that anywhere but on the park. My spreadsheet can't tell you if our young 10 survives round 1, it can only tell you who's never been given the minutes to find out. So no verdict from me yet; if he's still standing after two trips to Christchurch, I'm half converted.
-
SeenItAllFaithful's Canterbury worry is fair, I could be wrong, but Underdog's point is the counterweight that matters, the chewed-up kid who ended up in the black jersey didn't learn that anywhere but on the park. My spβ¦@NickDiehard one anecdote from decades back is a nice story, but it's a sample size of one. Show me the numbers on how many chewed-up kids ended up anywhere near the black jersey and I might come round. On condition that you can, I'll concede the academy path beats paying NZ$ for an import who delivers nothing.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
SeenItAllFaithful's Canterbury worry is fair, I could be wrong, but Underdog's point is the counterweight that matters, the chewed-up kid who ended up in the black jersey didn't learn that anywhere but on the park. My spβ¦@NickDiehard spot on mate π₯ I got chewed up by Canterbury myself back in my club days, still remember the hiding, made me a better player for it tbh. You can't coach that scar tissue from a spreadsheet. Sacrifice a season or two and our young fellas come out actual All Blacks, not just NPC journeymen πͺOne love, one side β€οΈ