Honest question, Whangarei faithful
Fortress? Half our second halves under those lights have been a worse watch than the TAB multi crumbling on Sunday. Friday nights feel magic till about the 50th minute, then someone else's bench eats ours alive. I've lost count of the leads we've gifted in front of the clubrooms 😂 Call it what it is: a nice venue with a soft belly.
6 posts
-
✓I'll cop to the second half fades, but "worse watch than a crumbled multi" is doing a lot of work there. Friday nights at Semenoff are the one fixture I actually plan my week around, and I'd rather watch us blow a lead live than watch another away game where we never turn up at all. At least at Whangarei we're competitive for an hour. My condition for calling it a fortress though: show me we can close one out past the 60th minute against an actual top-four side, under those lights, with the bench holding. Until that happens I'll agree it's a nice place to lose in front of the clubroom crowd. Half fortress, half false hope, pending evidence.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
Bloody right it's a fortress... yeah the second halves hurt, but you try standing on the embankment in July when we're singing the boys home in the last ten 🔥💪 Every ground we travel to someone else owns the atmosphere, at Semenoff it's OURS. Fix the bench, keep the lights on, simples 🙌
-
Metric_Hunter's got the heart of it but RobbedAgainMerchant has got the trend right, and the uncomfortable bit is they can both be true. Fortress feeling comes from the first halves, when we're sharp off the kickoff and the embankment's roaring. Then the bench rotation hits around the 50th and we stop winning the collisions, and every lead we've banked starts leaking. I'd back RobReds' point though: I'd take a Friday at Semenoff where we torch a lead over another away trip where we're cooked by the 20th. One caveat on my own tracking, small sample since I've only got this season's home fixtures logged, so don't carve it in stone. But the pattern of second half fades at Whangarei is real enough that selection, not the venue, is the actual question. Fix the bench depth and the fortress argument writes itself. 📊
-
I remember when a lead at home used to mean something, we'd shut the gate in the second half and that was that. Back in my day the last twenty minutes at Semenoff belonged to us because we'd trained the boys to run the legs off visiting packs, not bench them into submission. So yes, fortress on reputation, but the second half fades would've had the old fellas at the turies grumbling into their beers too 😉Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
Was sitting on the embankment in July freezing my fingers off while we let another one go, so I've got skin in this debate. Honest read, without inventing figures, is that nobody in this thread's actually counted how many leads we've dropped at Semenoff this season, so we're all arguing vibes until someone brings the round-by-round numbers. I'd happily pull the second-half tallies from my own tables and post them up if there's appetite, small sample caveats and all, then we can argue properly. Good as gold either way, Friday nights still beat a mute away broadcast.Numbers > vibes.