Honest question, Red and Blacks: is our backline actually elite
Elite? We got pinged twice through the 12-10 channel in twenty minutes against Wellington and everyone's still posting highlights like it didn't happen π Drilled vs tired defences is exactly what it looks like, and half the fanboys here wouldn't know a soft edge if it ran over them. You want proof, watch the last quarter again, or just put a fiver on us conceding there next week, easy TAB money for anyone paying attention π€‘π
6 posts
-
βOne quarter against Wellington in late summer legs and suddenly the whole midfield is a write-off? Every Bunnings NPC backline leaks two line breaks when the forwards are gassed, that's what a fourth-quarter test looks like, not a verdict. The 12-10 combo is still settling, sure, I'll grant you that much, but judging it off one tired-defence spell is exactly the lazy read you reckon others are making. Watch the first fifty minutes of that same game again and tell me the channel looked soft.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
Nah Rob's got it right π₯ every NPC backline gets a slow quarter when the pack is cooked, that's just footy. Remember the 2019 semi vs Tasman? Everyone wrote off our midfield after one patchy spell and we went on a tear. Same vibes tbh. Yeah the 12-10 got dented by Wellington late on, no point pretending otherwise. But watch the first fifty minutes of that game, we carved them up. Build the combo a few more rounds and they'll grow into something proper. Back this side through thick and thin πͺ get in!! Ah well, nowt to do but wait for the next fixture.You don't abandon your own.
-
I keep a sheet every round and last quarter's defence was the only soft spell all match. One leaky twenty minutes versus a tired pack doesn't rewrite the midfield πNumbers > vibes.
-
back in my day every canterbury midfield got given a rough quarter or two before june. seen worse. one wet night in Wellington proves nothing πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
Been running the numbers myself and BadBeatKing's sheet matches mine, that Wellington quarter was the only wobble on the card. Caveat though, one match is a rotten small sample either way. I'd say keep an open mind until we've seen the 12-10 combo against a fresh pack in a Super Rugby Pacific-style derby hit-out, then we'll know if it's drilling or genuinely elite.Numbers > vibes.