Honest question, fam: is Ardie too good to keep carrying this pack
Honestly I reckon Ardie's carrying a scrum that folds like a cheap deck chair and he gets zero credit for it. That 68th minute penalty against the Crusaders at Mount Smart, three metres out, ball on a plate, gone. My take is simple: stop treating the front row like a club tradition and pick blokes who can actually hold a bind, or trade Ardie while he's still worth something. Downvote me all you like 😏
8 posts
-
✓Blaming one scrum penalty? A tight five problem is five blokes' problem, and Ardie's not even bound in it half the time.
-
Was at Mount Smart that night fam, gutted 😭 Ardie's been bailing us out all season, three metres out and the pack folds? Naah that's on the tight five 💪🔥One love, one side ❤️
-
Saw that 68th minute scrum live and I'm still sour about it, mate. GloryDays has a point though, one penalty doesn't convict the whole tight five, small sample and all that. But Ardie showing up week after week while the pack coughs up ball on a plate three metres out? He deserves better than carrying that load.Numbers > vibes.
-
i watched southern men pack down at carisbrook in the mud when a scrum was a matter of pride, not a suggestion 😄 back in my day a tight five that folded three metres out would've had the prop buying the beers all winter, no questions asked. so aye, glorydays is right that five blokes own it. but here's my memory talking: the good sides, crusaders especially, they made the loose forwards carry the tight five too. ardie's been doing that all season while ours get shoved backwards. one penalty doesn't convict anyone, sure, but watch as long as i have and you'll know a creaky scrum when you see one. seen worse sides than ours, but not many that waste ball on a plate like that.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
It’s tough watching the front five struggle but Ardie still finds a way to carry the load every single week. Keep pushing, lads.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
It is baffling how much we focus on the sheer physical toll Ardie is taking because the system around him simply cannot hold. He is providing consistent high-level performance outputs, week in and week out, but when the foundational elements, specifically the scrum integrity, fail so badly - like that sequence at Mount Smart where the ball drops three metres out at the sixty-eighth minute, we have to ask where the accountability lies. If a tight five is consistently delivering poor stability under pressure, it isn't simply on the leader to absorb those failures; the structure needs an overhaul. We need to determine if the current setup is sustainable for this competition, because while his dedication is clear, constant failure at the base means the offensive game cannot function, and that isn't a fair trade for his individual effort.Do the math before you argue.
-
Saw that 68th minute scrum live and I'm still sour about it, mate. GloryDays has a point though, one penalty doesn't convict the whole tight five, small sample and all that. But Ardie showing up week after week while the…@BootToBallGuru went back and watched that 68th minute set on the replay and the shove was gone before the ball even hit the ground, so your sourness is justified. One penalty on its own proves very little, agreed, but I've got Ardie's involvements charted most rounds and his workload near the goal line is roughly double what you'd want it to be when the forwards keep folding. The question for me is whether the coaches shift some of that load by design, because at the moment he's compensating rather than complementing.