After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:52 am Log in Sign up

Honest question, crew: is our scrum actually a weapon now

club debate Canterbury Supporters Canterbury 18 posts ·159 views ·Posted: 15 Sep 2026, 3:30 am
Canterbury
Weapon, and anyone saying otherwise has clearly never watched a front row work in the wet. That Wellington maul was pure craft - forwards hitting in one motion like they'd drilled it all season, whistle or no whistle. You reckon the TMO gifted us that? Wait for the fanboys to pile in with their conspiracy charts 😏
GO GoTheDistanceOrNothing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 3:30 am

18 posts

  • ✓
    One drill doesn't make a weapon. Three clean scrum penalties across the whole match against Wellington? I'd want to know which ref we had before calling it craft.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    PA Paul_Fan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 6:25 am Quote
  • Nah Paul, watch the clip again 💪 that maul was TEXTBOOK. Ref could've blown anything and it was still rolling. Lucky? drilled that all season 🔥
    You don't abandon your own.
    SE SeenItAllFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 8:56 am Quote
  • Paul makes a fair point about wanting the ref's name before judging, but I've got the maul clip logged alongside my round tables and the Wellington pack was shoved backwards a good metre before anyone could even think about a whistle - that's pressure created, not gifted. I could be wrong, but three scrum penalties in one match against a/provincial front row like that usually reflects dominance rather than reffing. Chur, I'm firmly in the craft camp on this one.
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 11:43 am Quote
  • sitting through that maul clip took me straight back to the old Lancaster Park days, watching the red and blacks shunt province after province backwards off their own throw. the great packs never needed the whistle to win the hit, if anything the ref stayed quiet and let the forwards sort it themselves, and everyone just accepted that as proper rugby 😄 so watching our boys hit as one against Wellington, that metre of backward movement before anyone even looked at the TMO, well that's what tells the story. watch as long as I have and you'll get it, luck doesn't move a maul a metre with twelve fellas on the job. paul, name the ref if it helps you sleep, but a pack rolling like that earns the call wherever it goes. seen worse arguments on a saturday night in a car park, mind you 😉
    Canterbury goal celebration
    Been here longer than some have followed.
    UN UnderdogNightmare Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 1:01 pm Quote
  • Put NZ$20 on us at the TAB for a scrum penalty first scoring play next round and you'll see how confident I am 😏 when did a lucky side ever roll Wellington a metre uphill?
    RO RobBeliever Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 2:57 pm Quote
  • A metre uphill?? It was dead flat, Rob 😂 watched that clip three times... still reckon the ref helped us big time there 🤷
    One love, one side ❤️
    FU FullbackNut Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 4:05 pm Quote
  • Seen worse calls, mate, watch as long as I have and you'll get it. That maul moved a metre before the whistle blew; Wellington got out-muscled, plain and simple 😄
    Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
    SE SeenItAll_Guy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 7:24 pm Quote
  • Right, I'll give the maul one thing. The hit was clean and the drive went forward before anyone appealed, so I'll cop that it was craft. On condition that we're honest about the rest: Wellington's pack was defending short-handed near the line and they were hanging on from the second phase anyway. Any eight against a tiring defence there gets some joy. Scrum being a weapon though, I'm not convinced yet. One good outing in the wet proves you can do it, it doesn't prove the ref will keep rewarding it when we play a side with a beefy tight five. Show me the numbers over three or four rounds, if the penalties keep coming against proper scrummagers, then I'll happily say weapon. Until then it's a good day's work, nothing more.
    Canterbury stadium
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 15 Sep 2026, 10:51 pm Quote
  • RobbedAgainHater318 has it right, I reckon, clean hit, forward drive, craft. Caveat: one maul against a short-handed pack is a tiny sample, so I'm charting every scrum this round before I call it a weapon. 📊
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Sep 2026, 2:35 am Quote
  • Funny how everyone suddenly forgets Wellington were down a man at that point, eh? A short-handed pack holding a maul is like me backing a multi with six legs. Looks great till it collapses 😂. Craft all day for mine, fix's little spreadsheet can wait 🤡
    Any stat can be bent.
    BA BadBeatAndy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Sep 2026, 4:12 am Quote
  • Bit of both, fellas, c'mon 😂 you just know our lot never make it easy - craft for mine on the hit, but RobbedAgainHater318's right, a short-handed pack hanging on tells us bugger all about the scrum proper. Fix's spreadsheet might actually be worth the wait 🔥
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    FR FrontRow_Legend264 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Sep 2026, 4:41 am Quote
  • @FrontRow_Legend264 fair shout 😂 coached the juniors last week, same mixed picture honestly. The hit was all ours though, watch the tighthead prop drive 🔥💪
    VE VeteranSinceKid Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 5:49 am Quote
  • VeteranSinceKid wrote:
    @FrontRow_Legend264 fair shout 😂 coached the juniors last week, same mixed picture honestly. The hit was all ours though, watch the tighthead prop drive 🔥💪
    @VeteranSinceKid nah that tighthead drive was the best bit of the whole night tbh, kid folded like a deck chair 💪 I'm coaching juniors too and we drill that exact hit, so seeing it work at this level hits different. Our lot never make it easy but when the pack clicks like that? get in 🔥
    One love, one side ❤️
    MI MillieFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 5:49 am Quote
  • VeteranSinceKid wrote:
    @FrontRow_Legend264 fair shout 😂 coached the juniors last week, same mixed picture honestly. The hit was all ours though, watch the tighthead prop drive 🔥💪
    @FrontRow_Legend264 yeah I'm with you, one scrum against 14 men is a busted sample and I wouldn't put a cent on it meaning anything. What got my attention was the second wave onto the maul, that looked drilled rather than lucky. Wait for the full pack back before I touch any scrum-related line, honestly 💸
    Canterbury stadium
    Bankroll discipline wins.
    ST StatHeadnerd Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Oct 2026, 5:49 am Quote
  • beautifully unlucky this lot of ours, eh. reply: funny thing is, back in the day at Lancaster Park I watched front rows win tests with less than this mob showed in one maul against Wellington. you don't get a drive moving like that off a clean hit by accident - that's months of oil and grip work on the training paddock, hard out. and here's the counter-example: the scrums before that maul, even at full numbers, we steadied theirs twice without a whisper from the ref. no whistle, no free kick, just quiet dominance. the short-handed bit helps the scoreboard, sure, but it doesn't teach a pack to hit straight and stay bound. craft for mine, and I'll still take fix's spreadsheet with a cuppa when it's done 😄 ah well, we'll see
    Canterbury game moment
    Seen it all, lads.
    ME Metric_nerd Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Sep 2026, 8:17 am Quote
  • Six of one, half a dozen of the other from where I'm sitting, and the tape backs that up more than the whistle narrative does. I charted the hit against Wellington again last night - the bind and the dip on that maul were clean, forwards arriving in two waves with the jumper landing low, which is drilled work no referee can gift you. I could be wrong, but a short-handed pack changes the leverage maths so much that one sample tells us very little either way. 📊 So my honest position: craft on the execution, asterisk on the context. What would settle it for me is the next two scrums against a full pack, if the drops and rerights hold up when we're not rolling with the numbers advantage, then I'll happily call it a weapon alongside GoTheDistance. Until then the argument stays open, and Fix's round chart is exactly the right homework. Count me in the "worth the wait" camp.
    Do the math before you argue.
    FR FrontRowFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Sep 2026, 9:20 am Quote
  • That tighthead drive had me up off the couch screaming tbh 🔥 watched it three times and the kid just walked him back. My juniors will be copying that hit this week no doubt. Scrum a weapon? ask me again after they front up against a proper pack ah well, nowt to do but wait 💪
    Canterbury stadium
    You don't abandon your own.
    JO Josh_Christchurch Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 7 Nov 2026, 12:37 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.