Does the France v Springboks clash tell us more about the All Blacks?
Funny old November, isn't it. Back in my day the end-of-year tour was three hard train rides and a wet Tuesday in the provinces, now we get France and the Springboks both sitting top of the Nations Championship table. The Boks unbeaten on 15 points with that 130-49 goal difference, the French right behind them on 12 after a loss they'll want to bury. Whoever handles the Boks better on the 13th gives us a fair yardstick.
And I reckon it leans All Blacks rather than the Wallabies, though I'll hear arguments. Our lot have had the Boks' measure in patches these last couple of years, so watching how France cope with that brute of a pack at home tells you plenty about where Razor's side really sits. The Aussies are a different puzzle, all momentum and upset, harder to read from someone else's result anyway. Either way, tune in, it should be a cracker 😉
7 posts
-
✓Boks unbeaten, 130-49 across three games 😱 France will get smashed up front. Whatever happens there tells us more than any Wallabies game tbh. Ah well, nowt to do 💪🔥You don't abandon your own.
-
France at home with a fast pack? I'd be a nervous punter laying the Boks line tbh 😏 that 130-49 flatters a soft schedule, and reality bites on the 13th.Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
RobbedAgain, sample size of three, mate, so I'd pump the brakes on "soft schedule" as fact. A +81 goal difference in three matches is loud whatever way you cut it, and France conceding 75 themselves suggests they'll trade blows rather than shut the door. My worry as an ABs fan is whichever of these two wins on the 13th, that becomes the real measuring stick for Bledisloe form, and neither side we've put out lately would fancy either front five. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
BootToBallGuru makes the point I was going to make about sample size, though I'd add one more wrinkle: those 130 points came against sides who all defend differently to France, so the +81 tells us about ceiling more than floor. France shipping 75 in three games suggests the 13th turns into a shoot-out, and honestly that suits the Boks less than a grind would. I could be wrong, but I've kept my own table every round of this Championship and the pattern I keep seeing is that both these sides feast on broken field, so whichever pack holds shape longest probably decides it. For the thread's actual question, I'd lean the France game being the better mirror for us. The Wallabies matches tend to tell you about effort, the France game tells you about structure, and structure is what we get judged on at Bledisloe time. Small sample though, three matches each, so I'm holding my conclusions until the Italy and Fiji results are in the book as well. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Boks don't even get a breather either, Italy away then France then Ireland. Three weeks that'll tell us exactly where our lot stand 🔥In the stands since I was a kid.
-
Funny thing is I sat in the truck yesterday thinking about exactly this. Watched the great Bledisloe nights at Eden Park in the amateur days and the measuring stick was always the same: you found out what a side was made of against the Springboks, nobody else. So for me the 13th in France tells us more about the All Blacks than the Wallabies, simple as that. If the French pack, playing at home, can knock that unbeaten 15-point Boks run over, then whatever the All Blacks have shown lately looks better than it did. If the Boks go through France like they went through everyone so far, that 130-49 won't look flattered at all and our lot have real homework to do. Either way UncleAllDay is right, that November stretch will tell us plenty. Mind you, I've seen worse Novembers than this one 😄Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.