Canterbury's forwards have been carried by heart for too long
Sat through that first half on Saturday watching our scrum fold like a deck chair and thought I was watching a rerun from two years ago. Heart's carried this pack long enough, lads, the front row needs new bodies not another "back the boys" season. I've taken the TAB line on us getting monstered at set piece before, should've learned. Back your relic all you like, I'll be the one saying rebuild now. 😏
7 posts
-
✓
-
40 minutes of getting shunted at One NZ Stadium and we're still saying pre-season?? Nah, rebuild it now, heart doesn't win you scrums 🔥🤬You don't abandon your own.
-
I've been keeping my own table on the set piece this season and the Saturday half wasn't an outlier, it's a trend. Penalty count against us at scrum time sits ugly across the campaign, and the pattern is the same every week: we hold our shape for twenty minutes, then the hinge collapses once the bench legs come on. That's a conditioning and personnel problem, no amount of heart fixes a tighthead getting marched backwards. Where I land is between the two of yous. Full rebuild now? Probably overkill mid-cycle. But "pre-season and back the boys" ignores that we've said exactly that after the last two seasons and got the same 40 minutes at One NZ Stadium. So back the loosenies, keep the lineout, but the front row needs at least two new bodies brought in with real NPC minutes behind them. If a punter had put money on us winning a scrum penalty in that second half, the TAB would've paid out laughing all the way to the bank. 📊Do the math before you argue.
-
Seen it all before, boys. Late amateur days when Canterbury packs were feared across the country, the front row was rebuilt brick by brick, no sentiment, and that's why the scarfed jersey meant something. Saturday at One NZ Stadium looked like the 80s all right, just in reverse, so I'm with the rebuild crowd 😉Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
TaurangaBro's table matches mine, which is annoying because I hoped Saturday was a one-off. I've tracked scrum penalties week by week this season and the hinge collapse after the twenty minute mark shows up nearly every round, so one half at One NZ Stadium isn't the story, the campaign is. Only caveat I'd throw in, and I say this as someone who loves a spreadsheet: one season of club-level counts is a thin sample, so before we torch the lot we should check whether a couple of those penalties were refs guessing. Still, I sat in the stands watching our blokes move backwards like a reversing trailer and my brother next to me just said "again" quietly. That's enough for me. Back the loosehead and hooker, find a proper tighthead now, not in August. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Two tables saying the same thing is about as convincing as it gets for me, and I could be wrong but the twenty minute hinge pattern smells like conditioning or technique drift rather than luck. Still, I'd hate to torch four years of tight five chemistry off one campaign's sample. So where's the line between a rebuild and just a new scrum coach, honestly?Numbers > vibes.