Be honest, Force fam: is our whole game plan still built around one
Watching us set another maul for the thousandth time, I reckon we'd lose to the local under-12s if they got hold of the ball and ran π€‘ We out-kicked the Brumbies last season for nothing, deadset lottery ball, and finished bottom half for it. So which flyhalf actually gets told "have a go, mate", cos right now it looks like the coach wouldn't trust the backline with the seconds' bus money π
6 posts
-
βLose to under-12s? Did you watch the same season I did? Out-kicking the Brumbies only means nothing if your chase game is lazy. Show me the numbers.Hype isn't an argument.
-
Kev mate the chase WAS lazy, watched it from the stands all season π€ Run it in the heat, back the backs for once! Ah well, nowt to do π₯πͺYou don't abandon your own.
-
Kev, I've got the numbers you asked for, because yes I keep them round by round, and they actually help Dunedin's case more than yours. We out-kicked the Brumbies last season for territory and still finished bottom half of the table. If the chase game was doing its job, that pattern shows up as turnovers or at least a few wins off the back of it. It didn't. Same approach, same result, week after week. That's a sample of a whole season, not one lazy afternoon. Here's where I'd nuance it though. I could be wrong, but I don't reckon the kicking itself is the sin, it's that every kick looks identical, deep and contestable with no real pressure on the receiver. Kev's right that a sharp chase rescues bad ball, we've all seen sides live off it. But until the coach shows he trusts the backline at flyhalf, running it in the Perth heat stays a wish rather than a plan. Back the inside ball game when it's 35 degrees and the forwards are gassed, that's all most of us are asking πDo the math before you argue.
-
Back in my day a maul was something you used once or twice a match to make a point, then you flung it wide and hoped your winger could actually catch. Watched tests at Eden Park when the grounds were hard as a driveway and nobody thought twice about running from their own half. So this fear of playing in Perth heat has me scratching my head, honestly. Lock's numbers make the point well enough, we kicked more than the Brumbies and still sat bottom half, so it's fair to ask if the coach trusts the backs. My hunch is it's less about fear and more about a flyhalf nobody's backed properly yet. Give the lad some permission and a dry ball and see what falls out. Ah well, we'll see πSeen it all, lads.
-
Funny thing is I sat down after the last home game and started a maul-versus-run tally on the back of a kid's maths worksheet, gave up at the twenty-minute mark. The pattern was too obvious anyway. Lock's numbers sit right with mine, out-kicking the Brumbies for territory while sliding down the table tells me the kick itself was fine, the follow-up wasn't. Lazy chase, nobody contesting the restart, forwards trudging ten metres for another set-piece call. That's not a plan, that's a habit. Where I push back slightly on Metric_nerd is the weather excuse angle. Perth heat should suit us, SeenItAll is right about that, but running rugby only works if the flyhalf is trusted to call it and the backs get clean ball off nine. I genuinely don't know which candidate the coach rates, and until we see a pre-season trial with instructions to play, none of us will. So yeah, the question stays open for me. Is the maul the identity or just the safety blanket? Ask me again after round three πDo the math before you argue.