What exactly is a penalty kick in rugby union, in simple terms?
Sorry if this is a daft question, still learning this game properly π
But what actually is a penalty kick in rugby union? Like I see the ref blow the whistle and the team either kicks for goal or boots it out to touch - and I never really got which happens when and why.
Maybe I'm wrong but I thought the yellow card was the "big" punishment, so where does the penalty kick fit in? Is it only for serious stuff or any infringement? And when a team gets one, do they always prefer the 3 points or does taking a quick tap ever make more sense? Someone explain like I'm five please, and cheers in advance π
8 posts
-
βNot a daft question at all, mate, every one of us was puzzled by the whistle once π a penalty kick is what the ref gives when a team does something serious, like offside or a high tackle. The wronged team then has a choice: have a shot at goal for three points, kick the ball out to touch for an attacking lineout, take a quick tap and go, or ask for a scrum. Old school captains used to poll the goalkicker before deciding, these days they point to the posts more often than not, but touch is the option when the lineout catch is going well.Seen it all, lads.
-
Sorry to jump in with another basic one π but what if the kick at goal misses - do you still get points or nothing? Thanks Nick that helped heaps πDumb questions are my specialty.
-
Sorry to jump in with another basic one π but what if the kick at goal misses - do you still get points or nothing? Thanks Nick that helped heaps π@Dave_Faithful2007 nothing mate, zero points, drop-out from the 22 like Robbed said π FixIs is dreaming if he reckons Barrett nails every 45m bomb into a Wellington gale, I've watched blokes shank easier kicks than that at Carisbrook back when it existed. But yeah, that's why the corner option exists.Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
Dave, short answer: nothing. Miss the shot at goal from a penalty and you get zero, play restarts with a drop-out from the 22. If a kicker like Barrett is rattling home 80-something percent from reasonable range, three points is basically banked money, but from 45 metres out into a Wellington gale it's a coin flip, which is exactly why you see captains point to the corner instead. The myth worth killing while we're here: plenty of newbies think the team is somehow obliged to kick for goal because it's a "penalty kick". They're not. The three points are just one of four choices. A lineout five metres out with a rolling maul on song is often worth more in expectation than a dodgy long-range shot, and a quick tap catches the defence standing around moaning at the ref. Show me the numbers on conversion rates from 40-plus out in the rain and most coaches' choices start looking very rational.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Good question actually, and the easiest way to see the four options is to picture a real one: think of Beauden Barrett lining up a shot from 30 metres out after a high tackle, if it's kickable you take the three points, but if the touchline is close and the weather is foul you'll often see the captain point to the corner instead, going for the lineout drive. Quick tap works when the defence is still backpedalling and nobody's set, and a scrum is for when your pack is dominate.
-
Nah Robbed, the gale argument's soft - good kickers drill those π€¬ Barrett would nail it, backing them all day πͺ if it's missable you go to the corner instead π₯You don't abandon your own.
-
Ha, seen this debate since the amateur days π In short: a penalty kick is a ref-awarded punishment for a serious infringement, giving the team four choices β kick at goal for 3, kick to touch, quick tap, or scrum.Remember when the grass was greener π±