What does TMO actually decide, and why does the ref still overrule it?
Hi all, total newbie here so go easy on me π
I keep hearing the commentator say "up to the TMO" when a try gets checked, but then the ref still makes the call himself? If the TMO watches all the replays, why doesn't he just decide it? Sorry if that's a dumb question π
7 posts
-
βnot a dumb question at all, mate, the tmo is only there to advise, he checks the replay and tells the ref what he sees, but the whistle stays with the ref on the pitch. back in my day we didn't even have replays, so trust me this system's a luxury π the ref can go against the advice if his gut says otherwise, which frustrates punters no end, but that's how they keep a human in charge of it.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Can someone explain simply then, if the ref can ignore the TMO's advice, when would he actually do that? π€ Like if the TMO says no try but the ref was standing right there and saw it differently? Don't laugh guys π cheers for the answer btw πLearn something new every day.
-
Good question that, and no one's laughing π back in my day the ref just made the call and copped the abuse, replays came later. Simple version: the TMO is like a truckie's mate on the CB telling him what's up the road - useful eyes, but you're still the one holding the wheel. If the TMO says no try but the ref was right there and saw grounding clean with his own eyes, he can overrule, though these days he usually trusts the replay unless he's dead certain. Trust your eyes first, the telly second, old rule that works for refs too πWatch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
That CB analogy finally made it click for me π so basically the ref can say cheers for the view but still trust his own eyes? Still learning this, thanks everyone πDaft questions are my specialty.
-
Seen a few tries flipped because the ref trusted his own eyes and it cost me a leg of a TAB multi once, so this topic stings a bit π Practical version: the ref can absolutely go against the TMO's advice, but it's rare. Usually only when he had a clear view himself or the TMO says something like "no conclusive evidence" and he backs his on-field call. That's actually the default rule: what the ref gives on the field stands unless the replay clearly shows otherwise. So the truckie's mate analogy is dead on - TMO's extra eyes, ref holds the wheel. For a newbie punter the takeaway is simple: treat a tight try call near full-time like an unfinished bet until the whistle actually confirms it. I learned that loading up on a late try scorer leg, TMO check dragged on forever and the ref overruled it on a double movement. Didn't land, NZ$20 gone with it. Now I just assume the on-field call survives unless the replay screams otherwise π₯Bankroll discipline wins.
-
Lost a try-scorer leg the same way, ref waved the TMO off and my multi died with it π The funny part is I'd have copped it if the ref just trusted his own eyes from 5 metres out, half the time he's got the better view anyway. Now I just factor in that a flipped call can torch any leg, stings less that way πΊBankroll discipline wins.