Right, lads, time we finally sign a proper No. 10
Word is a certain Auckland first five-eighth might be off-contract and could be had for under NZ$80k. I'd drive him to training myself if we landed him. Our goal-kicking's been more tragic than the Albany carpark on match day. Imagine him slotting them under the lights while that wind does its worst 🤡😏
13 posts
-
✓Source on that? "Word is" usually means your cousin's mate at the TAB. I'll believe the NZ$80k bargain when I see him holding a Harbour jersey.
-
Even if it's just TAB gossip, imagine a proper 10 nailing penalties into that Albany wind 😱💪 we haven't had that in YEARS. Backing them all day 🔥One love, one side ❤️
-
GloryDays is asking the right question, because "under NZ$80k" for a first five-eighth with any NPC minutes is where this story loses credibility for me. If an Auckland 10 was genuinely off-contract and cheap, he'd have a queue of provinces, including a couple of the Bunnings unions who are just as desperate for goal-kicking as we are. Before we even get a look in. Cheap No. 10s usually come cheap for a reason: either the boots are suspect or the sample of good games is tiny. There's a nuance here too: we've been burned by mid-price recruits whose kicking percentages looked fine in a weaker competition and fell off a cliff against decent defensive lines. That said, the need is real. I've tracked our goal-kicking by round all season and it's genuinely costing us something like a converted try per game when you add the missed penalties to failed shot attempts from turned-over territory. If the club can verify the rumour and he's under 25, the price tag matters less than the trajectory.
-
An Auckland 10 going cheap while we're down to loose change in the coffers? I've seen the TAB pay out on wilder multi's tbf 😏 and honestly? we've signed "bargains" before, how'd that go 🤡Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
FixIsIn has it right, no 10 with real NPC minutes goes for under NZ$80k. I checked the union accounts last year over a few quiet ones, we couldn't even afford the warranty on the mower.
-
Tbh even IF we got him for under NZ$80k, one good 10 doesn't fix a pack getting shoved backwards every scrum... saw it live at Albany last season, no 10 kicks well with a front row going backwards 💀 get the tight five sorted first 🤬You don't abandon your own.
-
Tbh even IF we got him for under NZ$80k, one good 10 doesn't fix a pack getting shoved backwards every scrum... saw it live at Albany last season, no 10 kicks well with a front row going backwards 💀 get the tight five so…@StandsGuy88 fair point but I'd add a nuance: a struggling pack often looks worse when the 10 stands flat and holds the ball in, eating hits on the front foot line. With a 10 who releases early or kicks for territory, the same tight five concedes less pressure. I was at Albany too and the passing sequence made the scrum look worse than it was, though caveat: one match, small sample.@StandsGuy88 fair point but there's a nuance here: a struggling pack often looks worse when the 10 stands flat and takes the ball into contact, so the tight five keeps scrapping off the back foot.Numbers > vibes.
-
@StandsGuy88 fair point but I'd add a nuance: a struggling pack often looks worse when the 10 stands flat and holds the ball in, eating hits on the front foot line. With a 10 who releases early or kicks for territory, th…@BootToBallGuru saw the same thing down here watching the Bay boys in the Bunnings, new 10 releases quick and suddenly the scrum looks fine, funnily that. So are we paying NZ$80k for a halfback solution wearing a 10 jersey then? Just asking before someone signs the cheque 😏It's a lottery, not sport.
-
@StandsGuy88 fair point but I'd add a nuance: a struggling pack often looks worse when the 10 stands flat and holds the ball in, eating hits on the front foot line. With a 10 who releases early or kicks for territory, th…@BootToBallGuru that actually makes sense, cheers. So basically a good 10 hides a bad pack? Sorry if that's a dumb way to put it 😅Dumb questions are my specialty.
-
I could be wrong, but Josh_Legend's mower audit deserves scrutiny, quiet ones or not, nobody reads union accounts for fun, they read them looking for a scapegoat. Two different exercises. StandsGuy88, I'd push back a bit on the tight five argument. Have a look at the last few seasons and tell me a decent goalkicker wouldn't have flipped two, maybe three of those seven-point losses we shipped. A pack going backwards still gets you penalties — we earned plenty at Albany, we just couldn't bank them. That's the cheap part of the ladder to climb first. Hard out, sorting the scrum matters more long-term, but a 10 hitting 80% doesn't need the front row fixed to start paying dividends. As for the price tag. I'd want to see the contract actually before anyone drives him to training. 📊Do the math before you argue.
-
I could be wrong, but Josh_Legend's mower audit deserves scrutiny, quiet ones or not, nobody reads union accounts for fun, they read them looking for a scapegoat. Two different exercises. StandsGuy88, I'd push back a bi…@ChrisDiehard387 fair point on the audit angle - if the accounts are being combed, someone's hunting a fall guy. But sign a real 10 and half that pressure talk disappears. 🔥
-
we've heard this song before, lads - remember the big signing that vanished come winter? seen worse rumours though. time will tell 😉Been here longer than some have followed.