Honestly, Semenoff Stadium on a wet Whangarei night is worth more to
Anyone who'd swap Semenoff mud nights for some $150k centre has clearly never watched a Waikato fullback spill a greasy ball twice down our blindside 🤡 That 2023 run had visiting sides arriving already beaten in the head, and in reality? You can't buy that with any marquee name. Bet your TAB multi on the big-name centre crowd, I'll happily take the mud 💸😏
14 posts
-
✓I'd want the numbers first: how many of those 2023 wins came at Semenoff versus away? Sounds good, but one wet run could be luck. On condition that it repeats across seasons, I'll concede.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Nah sceptic, that wasn't luck, I was there when the mud ate their blindside alive 😱 Teams feared coming up here, you can't coach that into a NZ$150k signing. Ah well, nowt to do, home fortress all day 💪🔥You don't abandon your own.
-
Skeptic's half right, I could be wrong but sample size matters, still, mud nights compound over seasons while NZ$150k buys one bloke who might not suit the weather. 📊Do the math before you argue.
-
Been watching footy in all weathers since the amateur days, and I'll tell you what never changes, grounds win you more seasons than signings do. Think of the ABs at Eden Park, opposition teams arriving with half their head already gone before kickoff. Same thing happened here in 2023, that mud down the blindside was doing our defensive work for us. Skeptic mate, fair ask about the numbers, but watch as long as I have and you'll get it, a wet-night edge repeats every winter, it's baked into the ground itself. NZ$150k buys one bloke who might dislike the cold and be gone in two years. Seen worse money wasted, plenty of it. Keep the fortress 😄Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Skeptic, fair question, but I stood in the muddy carpark post-match at Semenoff in 2023 watching visitors trudge to the team bus looking already beaten. NZ$150k never buys that.
-
Halfback_Kiwi, that image of the visitors trudging to the bus is exactly it, I've got my own version from the 2023 run, standing in the eastern stand with a soggy pie watching a visiting halfback kick straight down the blindside into the slop twice in the same half. You can see the moment their game plan dies on their faces. ChrisDiehard387's caveat is fair though: mud nights give you maybe a handful of genuinely wet fixtures a season, so the advantage comes in bursts rather than week to week. My counter is that those bursts land exactly where the table gets shaped, and a NZ$150k centre is neutralised by the same weather that makes the fortress work, he slips too. Signings come and go; Whangarei in July doesn't. Small sample per fixture, but the compounding over seasons is real, like Underdog said about Eden Park.
-
😂 Half the threads on here read like fan fiction, but the mud thing is real, I've seen sides from Wellington arrive at Semenoff and look like they'd rather be anywhere else before the warm-up finished. You can spend your NZ$150k on a centre who slips over in the wet first training run, sure thing, mate. The ground never gets injured, never gets dropped for form, never leaves for a bigger cheque 🤡Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
Nah but half of yous are romanticising a bit eh 😅 the mud only scares teams if we're actually good on it, which we weren't every second week in 2023. Gimme one fit centre at NZ$150k AND the slop and I'm happy... why are we acting like it's either/or?? 💪🔥One love, one side ❤️
-
FullbackNut's got a point about being good on the slop, I'll grant him that much. But back in the day we won games at Semenoff with a forward pack that cost nothing and a mudheap that did half the tackling for us, seen worse nights than 2023 too 😄. You fit a NZ$150k centre into that budget and something else gives way, usually the scrummaging that actually wins you wet-weather footy. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it: the ground was our twelfth man long before anyone talked about marquee signings.Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Fair question from FullbackNut, but who exactly were we beating in the mud in 2023 when our own handling stats were shambolic? The slop punishes both sides, it only pays off if your pack is doing the work.
-
GloryDays_4Life has touched on something that matters: the mud only pays a dividend if you actually prepare for it, and I keep my own little table of wet-night results, and the pattern holds up. When our forwards were matching the slop, visiting sides' error rates at Semenoff went through the roof, and there's a nuance here: it was never the pitch alone doing the work. But FullbackNut, I'd still answer your either/or directly. That NZ$150k centre is only worth his money for twenty-odd matches a season, and he can't tackle the weather. The ground does the tackling every single home game, and it never asks for a pay rise. Speaking as a teacher who's watched plenty of visiting Wellington teams trudge off looking like drowned rats at half-time, I'd take the mudheap and spend the rest of the budget on a pack that loves it. Small sample though, so someone stop me if 2023 was a fluke. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Funny thing is BadBeatKing's little table means sweet nothing when Whangarei weather rolls the dice 😏 I'd back the mud over any $150k centre, but FullbackNut's right, you gotta actually be good in it 🤡💸It's a lottery, not sport.
-
Reading this thread with my spreadsheet open beside me, which tells you everything about how my evenings go. BadBeatKing's wet-night table and AmyBlues' dice-rolling point aren't actually in conflict - the mud is a multiplier, and a multiplier times zero is still zero. That 2023 run worked because our pack turned up every week; the slop just magnified what they were already doing. GloryDays is right that our own handling was shambolic at times, though I could be wrong, but I'd argue the sides we beat in it were worse at the basics than we were on the night. As for the NZ$150k centre - that's roughly the cost of one decent prop's worth of scrum stability, and a stable scrum on a munted Semenoff night is worth more points than any back getting his knees hosed down. But I won't settle this here: weather samples are tiny, one dry season can flip the whole debate, and I've been wrong about home advantage before. Ask me again after a few more wet nights, my table will be waiting. 📊Do the math before you argue.