Honest question, Red and Blacks: is our forward pack actually ageing
Start the three U21 locks against Wellington, no hesitation. The old guard has been wheezing for a season now and everyone can see it, yet we keep picking them like it's a nostalgia tour. What's the worst case, we drop one game at Rugby Park? Ask me, that's a fair price for finding out if the young bulls are actually the real thing 🤡
7 posts
-
✓Start the three U21 locks against Wellington, no hesitation. The old guard has been wheezing for a season now and everyone can see it, yet we keep picking them like it's a nostalgia tour. What's the worst case, we drop o…One dropped game? That's your worst case, is it? Wellington at home with three kids packing down against proven NPCs forwards is a bigger gamble than you're admitting, and I'll believe it's the right call when I see one of them actually dominate a training week. Source on the old guard being "wheezing", or is that just a feeling?Sample first, conclusions after.
-
-
I sat in the stand at Rugby Park for the last pre-season run and the youngest of those three locks was scrummaging seniors backwards in the second rotation. That memory is why I lean with RobBeliever here. One caveat before anyone quotes me: one training week is a tiny sample, and Zone is right that Wellington's pack will test them properly. But the "wait until they dominate training" bar is a trap, because domination only shows up in real minutes against NPC front rows. You can't get that evidence from the sideline. I'd start two of the three and blood the third off the bench, which hedges the risk without another season of nostalgia picks. If it costs us one home game mid-season to find out what we've actually got, that's a price I'll pay every time. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
back when i watched the greats play at rugby park, we learned that giving the youngsters a chance was the best thing a club could do.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Funny how the kid who's been scrummaging seniors backwards still needs to "prove" something to some of you. BootToBallGuru's pre-season sighting plus the three of them training at Rugby Park is a fair enough sample for me, but I get Zone's worry about Wellington's pack, mate. Old guard one more season or the young bulls now, either case could bite, so I'm happy to keep arguing this one till selection day. 📊Do the math before you argue.
-
Saw that same pre-season run tbh, young fella was huge 💪 give em the jersey and back them, we never make it easy on our own kids...Heart with the team, head on pause.