After Whistle
17 Nov, 8:06 am Log in Sign up

Does that 57 point loss to North Harbour outweigh the two wins after

Debate General Rugby Talk Northland 6 posts ·45 views ·Posted: 4 Nov 2026, 7:24 am
Northland
Watched that Harbour game back and the 57 tells you everything, honestly. Two good wins at Semenoff after it, sure, but Waikato and Wellington both turned up 34:17 and 52:28 style and nobody's asked Northland's defence a serious question since September. Then Counties Manukau stroll into Whangarei and score 22 with the game on the line, and suddenly the same cracks are there. Defence wins you a comp, the attacking flash just pays for a good night at the TAB. So nah, I don't buy "it matters less because we won twice after". The Harbour blowout is the only honest data point in the run. And in reality, would any of you have taken Northland conceding 57 plus 22 more a few weeks later if someone offered that line in early September? Didn't think so. 😏
RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 4 Nov 2026, 7:24 am

6 posts

  • ✓
    One bad afternoon in September and suddenly the defence is the whole story? Wellington put 28 on us a week after Harbour, so nobody's asking questions, sure, except they scored plenty. Waikato got held to 17. Might be the harbour game was just one of those days, might be it wasn't. I'll concede the Counties Manukau loss at home backs your point a bit, but two decent defensive weeks against one shocker isn't a trend, show me it repeating before I rewrite the season over it.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 5 Nov 2026, 1:38 am Quote
  • Nah Hater318, Harbour put 57 on us and Counties Manukau carved us up at Semenoff too, that's two proper questions asked and failed 😤 scoring 52 in Wellington means nothing when the last-gasp tackle keeps letting you down. You just know Harbour did the homework everyone else copied. Fix the defence or the flash doesn't matter 💪
    Northland game moment
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    MA Matchday_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 5 Nov 2026, 5:40 am Quote
  • That 57-point outing against North Harbour was definitely a massive red flag, and looking back, the vulnerability shown then became evident in the loss to Counties Manukau at Semenoff Stadium. You can't dismiss those defensive gaps just because the attack produced two high-scoring wins elsewhere; the defensive inconsistency across those early September fixtures is the real concern here.
    Numbers > vibes.
    BO BootToBallGuru Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 5 Nov 2026, 6:20 am Quote
  • man, the way these young guys chase the highlight reels with the tries, it reminds me of how things used to be. you had to respect the foundation, the real structure, you know? the attacking wins are good, but a defence that leaks 57 points away in a game like that? that's a huge worry, no matter how flashy the forwards are.
    Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
    OL OldSchoolEst66 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 5 Nov 2026, 6:48 am Quote
  • Hater318 has half a point buried in there, honestly. I keep my own table every round and the sample is genuinely small, three completed matches, so I could be wrong, but the pattern bothers me: Harbour 57, then Wellington still scoring 28, then Counties Manukau sneaking a last-gasp 22 at Semenoff. Three weeks of concessions, only Waikato's 17 sits outside it. Southland away on 2 October will tell us more than any of us can right now.
    Do the math before you argue.
    FR FrontRowFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 5 Nov 2026, 10:13 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.