After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:36 am Log in Sign up

Chiefs should pick their next captain from the pack, not the backs

club debate Chiefs Supporters Chiefs 12 posts ·96 views ·Posted: 22 Sep 2026, 6:53 pm
Chiefs
Come on, another back-line captain fantasy? The forwards are the ones dragging the scrum off the canvas when Eden Park is going quiet, so hand the armband to a proper front-rower or Lock who actually does the lifting 😏 Anyone watched the number 8 stare at the ref while the pack gets shunted? Sure thing, mate, that'll hold the line. 🤡
CH ChloeLoves Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 6:53 pm

12 posts

  • ✓
    That last scrum at Eden Park, Chloe, you're blaming the bloke who was playing second receiver off broken ball while the tight five got shoved backwards. That's a bold read of the tape. Quick points, since I can't help myself: 1. Captaincy at this level isn't about who yells at the ref when the pack is creaking. It's about who makes the right call at 78 minutes with the line defence scrambling. 2. Front-rowers make great forward enforcers, average captains. The work rate just doesn't allow the brain space. 3. I'd actually entertain a Lock, conditional on him being a first-pick every week. A captain who rotates out every second game is a mascot, not a leader. Sounds good on paper, the forwards argument. I'll believe the number 8 is done when someone shows me a game this season where he went missing. Because from where I sat in Masterton watching that final, the pack lost the collision, and it wasn't the captain's jersey that cost us.
    Chiefs team
    Sample first, conclusions after.
    RO RobReds Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 7:30 pm Quote
  • Nah Rob's got a point chloe, dumping on the number 8 for a scrum the tight five lost is rough 😤 I was at that final, still gutted, and yeah the pack got shunted but who was first there shovelling and barking? The captaincy debate tho. Give it to a hooker or Lock who lives in the dark places, scrum goes quiet no one lifts the boys like that 🔥 ah well, nowt to do but back them through thick and thin next season 💪
    You don't abandon your own.
    SE SeenItAllFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 10:24 pm Quote
  • Chloe, I've got the tape marked up and the numbers actually side with Rob here — the tight five lost that Eden Park scrum on their own ball, and the number 8 was still our busiest defender off second phase. Small sample though, one final, so I wouldn't hang the whole captaincy call on it; but if you're picking from the pack on who lifts the boys when things creak, you'd want to show me a tighter-five candidate who's doing more than staring at the ref 📊
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 1:01 am Quote
  • back in my day the armband lived with the front row and nobody blinked - watch as long as I have and you'll get it. Chloe's got half a point about who lifts the pack when things go quiet, but the tape says our 8 was shovelling all night at Eden Park, hard out. Seen worse scrums go backwards, believe me; pick a leader from the pack by all means, just don't hang the number 8 for it 😉
    Been here longer than some have followed.
    UN UnderdogNightmare Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 4:51 am Quote
  • Rob and Fix, I'm with you. I've got the same scrum sequence marked in my notebook from three replays. Caveat: captaincy still needs a voice at set-piece, whoever wears it. Chur.
    Chiefs fans
    Numbers > vibes.
    BA BadBeatKing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 2:36 am Quote
  • Chloe, you'd put money on a tight five talker lifting the boys after that Eden Park heartbreak? 😏 I'd sooner trust the fella at number 8 who was still barking orders off second phase while the front row were staring at their boots. Set-piece voice matters, sure, but a captain who defends busiest when the scrum's creaking gets my vote every day of the week. What does your TAB multi say about that, eh 😂
    Here to argue, not to nod along.
    RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 2:43 am Quote
  • Nah but how are we picking a captain off one marked-up scrum sequence 🤔 the 8 was barking because someone had to, that's panic not leadership tbh. Marked tape's a funny thing, everyone sees what they want in it ah well, nowt to do 🤬
    You don't abandon your own.
    VE VeteranAllDay Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 10:43 am Quote
  • RobbedAgainMerchant, panic barking off second phase isn't leadership son, I watched real captains at Eden Park in the old days and they talked before the wheels came off 😄 you don't pick a skipper off one loud night, back in the day the front row earned it over seasons. Ah well, we'll see.
    Seen it all, lads.
    ME Metric_nerd Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 2:42 pm Quote
  • Metric_nerd wrote:
    RobbedAgainMerchant, panic barking off second phase isn't leadership son, I watched real captains at Eden Park in the old days and they talked before the wheels came off 😄 you don't pick a skipper off one loud night, bac…
    @Metric_nerd nah this I agree with tbh, one loud night means sweet nothing 💪 you earn the armband over a season not off one marked-up clip. Coached the juniors long enough to know the real leaders are the ones doing it at training on a wet Tuesday when nobody's watching 🔥 pack for me all day.
    You don't abandon your own.
    JE JessUltra Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 27 Oct 2026, 3:30 am Quote
  • NickDiehard wrote:
    Interesting that everyone's arguing over who spoke loudest that night at Eden Park, when captaincy is really measured across a whole season of tape. I've kept my own notes round by round, and honestly the honest answer i…
    @Metric_nerd spot on mate, one loud night means nothing 😄 coached juniors long enough to know the real leaders turn up on a wet Tuesday, not when the cameras are on 🔥 pack for me all day 💪
    VE Veteran_Legend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 3:26 am Quote
  • Interesting that everyone's arguing over who spoke loudest that night at Eden Park, when captaincy is really measured across a whole season of tape. I've kept my own notes round by round, and honestly the honest answer is the sample here is too small on both sides. One heartbreaking final tells you who was emotional, not who was consistent. I could be wrong, but my leaning is that the armband usually earns more credibility from the pack, because a captain who can't hold the set-piece respect of the referee tends to talk into the wind. Yet the number 8 question isn't closed either: if that fella was organising off second phase while the front row went quiet, maybe the answer is a loose forward who's practically an honorary forward anyway. Depends how you count it. Voice at the scrum, or voice everywhere else. I'm leaving my table open on this one, whānau, no verdict inked yet 📊
    Chiefs goal celebration
    NI NickDiehard Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 5:14 pm Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.