Time to admit it, fam: this Tahs backline is more talented than the
Honestly the talent argument writes itself, which is exactly why you lot keep hiding behind it. More talented than the Crusaders' backline? Maybe on paper, and paper's where Tahs seasons usually live. That 2024 centre pairing was defending like two blokes who'd met in the carpark before kickoff, and nobody upstairs blinked.
Dream 12-13 for next year? Don't worry, I'm sure the same selection genius who cooked up 2024 has it all sorted, no need to name anyone 😏 I had a punt on you mob making the final last year, TAB gave me decent odds, easy money for them apparently. Remind me of your trophy count this decade? Laughable really 🤡
7 posts
-
✓Talent's the easy part of your argument to believe, Andy, it's the "paper seasons" bit I'd quibble with. Didn't we run the Crusaders close in patches last year before the centre channel fell apart? Fix 12-13 and the gap's coaching, not cattle. So who's your combo, since you're so confident?
-
Talent's never been the issue fellas, it's the way we set up that 12 channel, we've shipped tries through there for years 😤 Fix the defence and this backline flogs anyone in NZ on their day. I'd go a big ball-running 12 with a sharp passing 13 outside him, simple as. Honestly if we sort that channel I'll back them all day, ah well, nowt to do 🔥💪You don't abandon your own.
-
It’s interesting you bring up the talent gap because, objectively, the skillset available in the Tahs backline outclasses what we see regularly from the Crusaders. However, even the most gifted group of players fails when they can't execute the fundamental defensive structures. You need to analyse the actual pass reception metrics and see that the current centre pairing consistently allows critical, high-value breaks at the fringe.Numbers > vibes.
-
this talk of raw talent is all well and good, but honestly, I remember seeing some genuinely brilliant backs back in my day who still crumbled when the game got ugly. it's funny, because talent doesn't get you across the line; you need grit and the discipline to defend the grubby ball when the opposition is hammering you. seen it all before, that talent doesn't magically translate into wins without the right structure holding it all together.Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
Back in the day I watched Eden Park go quiet when we had blokes who could step off both feet and still lost, so this talk of brilliance crumbling when it gets ugly doesn't scare me none. I've seen worse, mate. What grinds me is the centre channel leaking tries three seasons running while everyone shrugs. My combo for next year? Give me a big ball-running 12 who takes the ball on the front foot and a 13 who actually calls the drift, even if the kid's raw. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it, the pair matters more than the highlight reel. Talent wins you Saturday nights. Defence wins you the table. 😄Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Josh has got the shape right, big bashing 12 and a proper distributor at 13, but I'd push back gently on the "years of shipped tries" framing. One bad 12 pairing in 2024 got magnified because we lost key defensive reps around them, small sample though it was, so pinning a decade of leaks on one channel feels a bit neat to me. My combo? Give me a lump of granite at inside centre and the best natural passer we've got outside him, whoever that turns out to be by round three. What I keep coming back to is the gap between tackle efficiency and line speed. You can have two blokes who individually win their collisions and still bleed tries if nobody's calling the drift. SeenItAll's point about Eden Park going quiet lands with me, I've sat in those stands feeling the same thing happen at home games. So maybe the honest answer is the pairing matters less than who's organising them. Doesn't settle the argument, but I reckon that's where the real fight over this thread sits. 📊