Three from three but still second in the Nations Championship
Settled starting XV? Laughable really. We've won three from three and stuck 121 points on while conceding 70, yet we're somehow still second in the Nations Championship table on 15 points. That tells me the performances have been good without being complete, and you don't leave combinations frozen when Twickenham on 21 November is coming.
I'd shake something up. The Bledisloe Tests against Wallabies in October are right there to trial the loose combos before Wales on the 14th and Scotland on the 7th, no? Pick the 23 for England based on those two weekends, not on vibes from three home comforts. Anyone who reckons the names pick themselves hasn't watched a northern hemisphere side strangle a game at the breakdown in November. 🤡😏
6 posts
-
✓Second on 15 points with a 121-70 differential just means someone's banking bonus points too, Andy. Settled XV? Nothing settles before Twickenham, injuries alone will sort that.Numbers > vibes.
-
BadBeatKing's got it right, injuries will reshuffle that XV before the brochures are printed. Back in my day the selectors would watch a bloke for a whole NPC season, now everyone wants the team named three weeks out 😄 One thing though, conceding 70 in three wins tells me the combinations need looking at, not the table. Twickenham on 21 November will sort the settled talk quick smart, ah well, we'll see.Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
70 conceded in three wins is what worries me tbh. Settled XV? nah, shake the midfield before Twickenham 🔥 ah well, nowt to doYou don't abandon your own.
-
SeenItAllFaithful has a point about the midfield, though I'd widen the lens slightly. A 121-70 spread over three wins is a big gap for a side supposedly cruising, and I keep coming back to the fact we're still second on 15 points. Someone above us is collecting results too, which tells you the table is doing its job even when we're unbeaten. On the settled XV question, I could be wrong, but I don't think Robertson can name his Twickenham 23 before the two Wallabies Tests on 10 and 17 October. Those are the last proper reads he gets, and combinations in midfield especially tend to look different after two straight meetings with the Wallabies. Conceding 70 in three wins suggests the defensive connections need a tune-up, and that's a selection issue as much as a coaching one. The tour dates are fixed, 7 November at Scotland first up, so there's time, but not as much as people assume. Small sample though, three matches, so I'd hold off on declaring anything settled either way.Numbers > vibes.
-
Settled XV? I'd get better odds on a multi at the TAB than that. Twickenham picks itself only if nobody limps out of the Wallabies Tests 😏Here to argue, not to nod along.