After Whistle
17 Nov, 8:07 am Log in Sign up

The Tahs should rebuild around the academy kids and let the big-name

club debate New South Wales Waratahs Supporters New South Wales Waratahs 10 posts ·84 views ·Posted: 16 Oct 2026, 3:35 pm
New South Wales Waratahs
Watched the last few games and honestly the only blokes who looked like they wanted to be there were the academy kids. The big earners have been coasting all season, why are we scared of losing them? Nobody else is lining up to pay those wages anyway. And in reality, what have the signings bought us? Another season watching the ladder from underneath. Give the young centres a full run next year, eat the losses, and let's see who actually wants the jersey. Anyone brave enough to back the rebuild or is everyone happy keeping the comfy names and the same results? 🤡
RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Oct 2026, 3:35 pm

10 posts

  • ✓
    "Nobody's lining up to pay those wages" is doing a lot of work in your post, mate. Source on that? Japanese and French clubs hoover up experienced Super Rugby forwards every off-season, and a full rebuild on teenagers usually means a couple of wooden-spoon seasons first. I rate the academy kids too, but a backline of kids gets dismantled in the derbies, the Crusaders alone would feast on that.
    GL GloryDays_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Oct 2026, 4:11 pm Quote
  • Spoon seasons? we've basically had one already mate 😂 those academy kids were the only ones throwing passes with any chest on them, I'd rather watch them learn for two years than pay big coin for blokes coasting til the Japan window opens. Give the kids the full run, I'm all in 💙
    You don't abandon your own.
    GA Gary_Blues Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Oct 2026, 6:31 pm Quote
  • Funny thing is I keep my own table every round and the academy centres' minutes actually correlate with our best defensive spells this season, small sample caveat and all, but the eye test matched the spreadsheet for once. GloryDays is right that Japan will pay for experienced forwards, yet that's precisely the argument for moving them on while there's still a market. Two wooden-spoon years is a fair price if the payoff is a core that actually wants the jersey. 📊
    New South Wales Waratahs stadium
    Numbers > vibes.
    BO BootToBallGuru Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 16 Oct 2026, 7:58 pm Quote
  • seen it all before, mates. you gotta gamble on youth, just like back in my day.
    Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
    FI FixIsInBeliever680 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Oct 2026, 3:38 am Quote
  • You know, after watching the centre pairing last Saturday, I reckon Gary's got the right instinct, honestly. While the immediate payoff of those marquee players is undeniably tempting, you have to remember that developing the academy talent is a slower return on investment. My personal take is that if we force them into too much high-pressure Super Rugby Pacific minutes before they're ready, the statistical increase in errors negates any developmental benefit.
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 17 Oct 2026, 7:14 am Quote
  • Funny how the "slower return on investment" crowd never mention whose investment it is, eh? Us mugs paying membership plus NZ$30 a match to watch marquees audition for Japan 😏 Yeah nah, give the kids the run, worst case we lose ugly and learn something. What's the marquee actually going to win us next year, fifth?
    RO RobBeliever Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 8:21 am Quote
  • Nah Rob, I back the kids too but honestly who scares me losing them? Every academy star we've unearthed lately ends up in Auckland or Canberra anyway 💪🔥
    New South Wales Waratahs game moment
    One love, one side ❤️
    MI MillieFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 12:54 pm Quote
  • Man, it feels like we're arguing over the exact same split decision every season, doesn't it? I reckon we need a plan that respects the hunger of the academy kids but doesn't just throw away all the consistent quality we've paid for so far. It’s definitely a massive gamble to ditch the big-ticket names entirely for promising youngsters right now.
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 18 Oct 2026, 11:52 pm Quote
  • Honestly Millie's point is the whole problem wrapped up in one post. What's the point of blooding kids if Auckland and Canberra just lift them the second they look the part? Might as well paint a sign on the academy door saying free talent, help yourselves. Chris wants a "plan", loveable, but we've had a plan for years and it's the same split decision dressed in a new shirt every season. Rob's onto something though, I'm not paying my NZ$30 to watch some marquee have a stroll before his flight to Japan. Play the hungry ones, even if they get pumped for a season. Fanboys will say you can't write off the big names. Watch me 😏
    Here to argue, not to nod along.
    GO GoTheDistanceOrNothing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 6 Nov 2026, 7:27 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.