After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:46 am Log in Sign up

Right, lads. Who's our dream Lock to partner Scott Barrett in 2025?

club transfer wish All Blacks Supporters All Blacks 13 posts ·96 views ·Posted: 21 Sep 2026, 6:00 pm
All Blacks
Saw a couple of the boys from the club night grinning about something and now I know why, apparently there's chatter a certain 2.05m Cantabrian might be heading home from Japan, NZ$1.2m a season being thrown around. Half the room reckons it's rubbish, the other half already picking their TAB futures. Imagine him and Scotty at lineout time though 🤡💸
RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 21 Sep 2026, 6:00 pm

13 posts

  • ✓
    NZ$1.2m from a club night rumour, who exactly was doing the talking, the bar tab or someone with actual signing knowledge? Source on that? Last bloke who "had a mate in Japan" had us signing three players who retired years prior, so I'll believe it when NZR announces it.
    GL GloryDays_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 7:18 pm Quote
  • Even half true at NZ$1.2m you pay it, no questions 🔥 Imagine that lineout with Scotty, opposition throw-ins would be terrified 💪
    All Blacks game moment
    In the stands since I was a kid.
    UN UncleAllDay Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 7:36 pm Quote
  • GloryDays has got a fair point on the source, but I'd temper the scepticism slightly. Big second-five... sorry, big locks coming home mid-30s from Japan is a pattern we've seen before, and NZR has form for paying over the odds precisely because the pool of Test-ready locks is thin. The nuance here is age versus role: a 2.05m lineout specialist doesn't need the work rate of a 26-year-old, he needs the jump and the org skills, and those age well. Scotty does the heavy carrying, the tall fella just calls and claims. Small sample though, I've tracked sabbatical returns in my own tables and roughly half of them deliver in year one, the rest fade by June. At NZ$1.2m you'd want the lift to be immediate, no settling-in period. Verdict: plausible, maybe 40% in my book, and I wouldn't touch that market at the TAB at those odds either way. UncleAllDay's right that if it lands, the lineout becomes genuinely frightening.
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 10:51 pm Quote
  • I could be wrong, but I'd want to see the contract before anyone starts pricing the second-row partnership. FixIsInPTSD, the "locks coming home mid-30s" pattern cuts both ways. For every success story there's a bloke who spent the season in the medical room while we all pretended the lineout was fine. At NZ$1.2m a season, NZR would be paying for name recognition as much as jumping ability, and that money could cover two younger locks with actual Super Rugby minutes behind them. UncleAllDay, sure, a 2.05m frame next to Scotty sounds lovely on paper, but the Bledisloe isn't won at lineout time alone, you need mobility round the park and someone who can scrum for eighty minutes. A decade in Japan slows the legs, whatever the highlights reel says. My dream partner for 2025 is whoever's been grinding through the domestic season and knows the current tempo, not a nostalgia signing with a rumour price tag. Prove me wrong and I'll happily eat my words, but I'd like a source first.
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 1:08 am Quote
  • that $1.2m talk reminds me of when we all got worked up about a certain flanker coming home in the amateur-pro crossover days, and he turned up a stone overweight and two steps slow 😄 ChrisDiehard's right to pump the brakes, back in my day we waited for the union to actually name the side before writing the team talk. lovely dream though, that lineout would be something to see.
    Seen it all, lads.
    UL Ultra88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 4:07 am Quote
  • Funny how the same blokes crying about our thin Lock stocks suddenly want receipts when a fix might walk in 😏 I'd be down the TAB on that lineout pairing tomorrow.
    All Blacks team
    Any stat can be bent.
    SU Supporter_88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 8:08 am Quote
  • ChrisDiehard's right. I'd take him back on condition the body's still holding up, saw Whitelock's last year here, the wheels go quick at that age.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 12:36 pm Quote
  • Even at NZ$1.2m, a fit Brodie with Scotty would be worth every cent 🔥 wheels worry me a bit tbh but id take that punt ah well, nowt to do
    You don't abandon your own.
    VE VeteranAllDay Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 3:59 am Quote
  • VeteranAllDay wrote:
    Even at NZ$1.2m, a fit Brodie with Scotty would be worth every cent 🔥 wheels worry me a bit tbh but id take that punt ah well, nowt to do
    @VeteranAllDay same mate, I'd pay that in a heartbeat for Brodie next to Scotty 🔥 remember watching him bully the Boks lineout years back, absolute domination. Wheels gone or not, you don't turn down that pairing if the body holds.
    All Blacks fans
    You don't abandon your own.
    SE SeenItAllFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 1:15 am Quote
  • Funny how half this thread has turned into a physio assessment nobody's qualified to give. Depends how you count it, but Retallick's been playing regular minutes in Japan, and the there's a nuance here: Japan's pace is a walk in the park compared to a Rugby Championship Saturday. That cuts both ways, fresh legs, or a bloke who hasn't been hit properly in months? And Supporter_88, "thin Lock stocks" is doing a lot of lifting in your post. Who exactly are we thin behind? The NPC has been throwing up second-rowers all season, most of them twenty-something and hungry. Pay one veteran NZ$1.2m and you've blocked two of them for a year. I'd rather see Scotty partner a developing talent with a real sample size of minutes than punt the house on a fairytale reunion. At the TAB, mind, I might still have a small multi on it, hedging my principles, as you do 📊
    Numbers > vibes.
    BA BadBeatKing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 4:39 am Quote
  • I've heard this tune before, lads, remember when a certain big name was "definitely" coming home from Japan a few seasons back? Sitting at the pub with the boys, everyone certain, and then nothing. A lineout with Scotty and that 2.05m frame would be a lovely sight, but I'll believe it when the bloke's holding the jersey. Time will tell. 😉
    All Blacks fans
    Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
    FI FixIsInBeliever680 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 8:42 am Quote
  • Word going round the club scene is Brodie's body isn't the worry people think 😏 won't say more than that. Seen blokes come back from Japan looking five years younger than they left, pace over there is a different beast alright. Lineout with him and Scotty would be silly good though 🤫
    All Blacks goal celebration
    Those who know, know.
    FA Fanatic_Faithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 27 Oct 2026, 12:57 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.