Right, be honest - who do we want wearing the No. 10 jersey after the
Word from the camp is selectors want a young ten to shadow the incumbent through this cycle, and honestly my pick would be whoever looks sharpest in the Super Rugby Pacific derbies this season. Blindside note: word is one of the Crusaders youngsters has been telling people he's on the radar already, take that with a grain of salt though, mate of a mate stuff.
And in reality? Half these "frontrunners" at 22 are toast by 26. Ask any punter who's thrown NZ$50 on a "next great All Blacks ten" multi and never seen it land. 🤡💸 So who's your tip, and more awkwardly, which province are you pretending not to be biased from? 😏
12 posts
-
✓"Word from the camp" — whose camp, exactly? Last time one of these anonymous whispers did the rounds we all ended up looking silly. I'll believe there's a succession plan when the selectors actually name a shadow in the squad, and not a minute before. Show me a source or it's just another TAB multi of rumours someone lumped together over the weekend.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
Fellas, I just want someone with ICE in the veins at 10 🔥 whoever shines in the derbies gets my vote, build him now, Bledisloe waits for no one 💪One love, one side ❤️
-
Teaching teenagers for a decade has taught me one thing: promising and ready are two different age groups entirely, and selectors forget that at their peril. A young ten shadowing the incumbent through a World Cup cycle sounds tidy on a whiteboard, but the maths is tighter than people think. If the incumbent is, say, 27-29 at the start of the cycle, the shadow gets four years of bench minutes and a handful of midweek fixtures. That's a small sample to judge anyone on, and by the next tournament the kid is 24-25 with maybe a dozen caps, which is exactly the sort of résumé that collapses under a Bledisloe pressure night in Wellington with the line closing tight. So when I price this "transfer" realistically, I'd say it only works if the shadow is already 22-23 and starting week in, week out for his Super side. Younger than that, you're developing a passenger; older, and the succession logic evaporates because the incumbent is still the best option at the next World Cup anyway.Numbers > vibes.
-
BadBeatKing, I'd push back gently on the "promising and ready" split, Carter was barely shaving when we threw him in, and Dan himself got minutes as a teen. Sample sizes here are tiny, sure, but every great ten we've had got test reps well before anyone called him ready. Where RobReds has a point is the sourcing; I'll believe the shadow plan when it's in an actual squad list. That said, shadowing through a cycle means Super Rugby derby form matters more than usual, and that's the one metric we can actually watch week to week 📊 So my needle for the room: if the selectors DO name a shadow, do we trust them to give him proper minutes, or will he sit in cotton wool for two years and learn nothing?
-
Carter got thrown in because we had nobody else, mate. A succession shadow is a different beast. Rare is the young ten who warms the bench two years and stays sharp.Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Genuine question, seen the kid play live? Warm bench for two years and everyone forgets how ruthless Super Rugby derbies are 🤡 Remind me of your ROI on "ready" calls, FixIsInPTSD?😏Any stat can be bent.
-
SeenItAll_Guy has it right, bench-warming kills rhythm, and I've watched plenty of promising tens go flat in the Super Rugby derbies. Concede the point on one condition: whoever shadows gets proper minutes, not token cameos.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Hated watching our last great ten rot on the bench, so back RobbedAgainHater318 - shadow role with real minutes or don't bother 💪🔥 ah well, nowt to do but trust the selectors ehYou don't abandon your own.
-
heard this same whisper before every cycle, lads. half of them never see a test jersey. proper minutes or nothing, and time will tell 😉Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Fair jab Gary 😄 yes, I've watched him live for my provincial side a couple of times when the census town turnout was thin, and he looked every bit a young ten, sharp one week, rattled the next. Back in my day the herd got behind a kid after two good NPC games and then wondered why he went quiet at Eden Park. Proper minutes is the only currency that means anything, so RobbedAgain's condition sounds right to me.Remember when the grass was greener 🌱
-
Not getting real game time means that consistency needed for a good bet is going to be totally absent.Bankroll discipline wins.