Beauden Barrett should never start another big match for the All
Nah mate, one rough night with the boot in a quarter-final doesn't erase a bloke's whole career π€‘ You want Beauden gone, fine, but then tell me who's wearing 10 instead and honestly, at least I got cheeky odds on the TAB for him slotting that dropped goal. Remind me of your ROI again before you pick a lineup? π
18 posts
-
βNah mate, one rough night with the boot in a quarter-final doesn't erase a bloke's whole career π€‘ You want Beauden gone, fine, but then tell me who's wearing 10 instead and honestly, at least I got cheeky odds on the TABβ¦Funny how "one rough night" needs defining first. Do you mean the quarter-final against Ireland alone, or the pattern across big matches? Because the argument was never about a single game. And the TAB anecdote cuts both ways. Being a punter who won a few dollars on a dropped goal doesn't make the selection call right. Who replaces him? Fair question, but that's the lazy version of it. Ian Foster had a full squad pool and kept defaulting to familiarity. Mo'unga was there, clearly. The boot at goal is only part of it; it's game management when the pressure's on. Gut feeling says "career balance", but show me the numbers on second-half leads surrendered in knockouts and we can talk. Until then I'm not accepting "one bad night" as a shield.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Beauden's still got more big-match X-factor than anyone we've got π€ That Ireland night hurt but you don't chuck a two-time World Player of the Year over one kicking shocker π€Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
GloryDays has a point buried in there, and I could be wrong, but the sample size argument runs both ways. Two-time World Player of the Year buys you patience in June tests, sure. Yet the reason Foster kept turning to Richie Mo'unga for the biggest 2023 fixtures tells you the coaches had quietly stopped trusting Beauden at 10 when everything was on the line. One bad night against Ireland? No. But the pattern around that night is the worry, and I'd want the tape checked before we hand him another quarter-final.Do the math before you argue.
-
Watched first five-eighths get roasted since the days when missing touch meant a hiding from the whole country, and I'll say this: every good 10 we've had has had a bad night at the worst moment - Andrew Mehrtens in '95 springs to mind. Beauden's kicking wobbles have been creeping in for years though, so the Ireland quarter-final felt less like a shock and more like the bill arriving. Still, back in my day we backed our men through the rough patch. πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
Underdog hit the nail on the head with the Mehrtens point, I was at a sports bar in Wellington during that 2015 semi and even then the old boys were comparing boot dramas across generations. Every great 10 we've had has one night they'd pay to forget. Caveat though, and I say this as someone who's kept kicking stats in my notebook since 2019: Mehrtens' '95 miss got forgiven because he'd banked years of clutch performances before it. The question with Beauden is whether the ledger balances the same way anymore. Depends how you count it. Count the running game and the two World Player of the Year awards and he's still elite; count only pressure kicks in knockouts and the pattern is harder to wave off. My personal worry is less the boot itself and more that Foster kept riding him at 10 when the game had shifted to territory-first. That's a selection problem wearing a player's face.Numbers > vibes.
-
Funny how everyone suddenly remembers Mehrtens in '95 when it's their favourite needing an alibi π Beauden's had a decade of October nights to fix the boot. Cracks me up really.Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
Interesting how GoTheDistance rates a decade of October nights but ignores two World Player of the Year awards π€ selective memory much ah well, nowt to doYou don't abandon your own.
-
SeenItAllFaithful has it right, two World Player of the Year gongs don't grow on trees, bro. And for every old-timer like me remembering a bad kicking night, I can remember Beauden tearing the wallabies to shreds at Eden Park with ball in hand. A dodgy quarter-final boot doesn't wipe out a decade, simple as that πWatch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Fun fact nobody's mentioned yet: Beauden didn't even want to be the goalkicker that night in Paris. Foster kept him there over McKenzie and Mo'unga, and once the yips start in a quarter-final against Ireland with the line pressing, no amount of talent saves you. Show me the numbers on that call and I'll concede Foster owns more of it than Beauden does. Not convinced he should start a knock-out match again, mind. Ball in hand, running game, offloads, brilliant, two World Player of the Year awards don't lie. On condition that someone else holds the kicking tee. If the plan is Beauden at 10 AND taking the shots, then yeah, we've seen how that film ends.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
RobbedAgainHater318 has got it spot on, and it's the part of the story this thread keeps missing. Foster picked his kicker for that Ireland quarter-final in Paris, and once Beauden missed the conversion from in front and the second one went off the tee under pressure, the whole selection logic looked upside down with McKenzie and Mo'unga sitting there. That's a coaching call before it's a player failure, if you ask me. My own caveat though: I keep a sheet on his tee stats going back years, and even before 2023 the pattern was clear. Clinical from the tee in July, wobbly once the pressure ramps past about 70% expectation. Small sample though when you slice it that finely, there's a nuance here between "bad night" and "bad under QF intensity", and the tape says the latter was always lurking. Ball in hand? Still elite. But I sat in Eden Park in the drizzle watching him carve the Wallabies open and still thought: don't let him tee it up in a knockout.
-
Love how everyone's suddenly a selector π RobbedAgainHater318 reckons it was all Foster's fault, yet the bloke still pulled on the 10 jersey and fluffed it. At some point the boots on your own feet count for something, eh. Here's my actual take: nobody's saying bin him from the squad, but start him in a big one again? Sorely naive. The ABs have Mo'unga-tier options and a whole Super Rugby Pacific season of derbies to blood someone with nerves that don't shatter when the line's pressing. Two World Player of the Year gongs were earned running the ball against tired forwards, brother, not off the tee in Paris. Big matches are decided by those kicks now. Remind me of your ROI on backing him next time? ππΈAny stat can be bent.
-
Nah RobbedAgainHater318, "he didn't want the tee" doesn't cut it with me bro π€ You're telling me a two-time World Player of the Year can't say nah, I'm not kicking? Beaver's a big boy, he wears the jersey, he owns the misses π€¬ Fear of the yips before a quarter against Ireland should've had him stepping aside himself. πͺπ
-
@OldSchool_SinceDayOne2012 pressure does funny things bro, even to the greats π€¬ you ever kicked in front of 80k with the line screaming at you? I haven't either, so I'm not gonna pretend it's simple. Beaver owns the misses fair enough, but whoever handed him the tee wears some of it too π€One love, one side β€οΈ
-
@OldSchool_SinceDayOne2012 pressure does funny things bro, even to the greats π€¬ you ever kicked in front of 80k with the line screaming at you? I haven't either, so I'm not gonna pretend it's simple. Beaver owns the missβ¦@FullbackNut fair point about pressure, but from where I sit it's simple money. Punters price the goalkicker before they price anything else, I had BB in a multi that weekend precisely because he was taking the tee, and when the tee went sideways the whole ticket went sideways with it. Selection staff know punters and coaches read that stuff the same way, so if there was doubt in his boot, someone should've made the call before kickoff, not after the third miss. Beaver owns the misses, yeah, but you don't hand a shaky tee to a bloke mid-crisis and hope. Coaches get paid to make the cold call. If the yips were live, start him at first five and give the tee to the specialist. That's not hating on Beauden, that's just how you protect both the result and the player.
-
@FullbackNut fair point about pressure, but from where I sit it's simple money. Punters price the goalkicker before they price anything else, I had BB in a multi that weekend precisely because he was taking the tee, and β¦@Diehard_Zone that makes sense actually, never thought punters read the team sheet for the tee before anything else π dumb question maybe, but does a missed multi change how you rate him, or just your wallet?Dumb questions are my specialty.
-
Interesting how this thread has quietly turned from "drop Beauden" to "who handed him the tee", eh? I could be wrong, but if the yips were kicking in (pun intended) with the line pressing against Ireland, then the selection call deserves at least as much scrutiny as the misses. Context matters - I'd want to see how he went off the tee in the tests either side of that quarter-final before writing off a two-time World Player of the Year over one Paris night.
-
Put a cheeky $20 on BB topping the point scorers that night and it didn't land, so believe me I've paid my emotional tax on those misses π But the tee question is fair. Every punter knows the difference between a bet you picked and one the TAB threw at you by default, that's what the kicking duties felt like. If the bloke's head wasn't right off the tee, the coach should've seen it and moved on. That said, starting him again in a big one? Yeah nah, I'm with the title. You don't hand your best footy's biggest moments to a guy whose yips showed up when it mattered. Selection call wears at least half of it, no argument there.Bankroll discipline wins.