Beauden Barrett's best years are behind him and the No. 10 jersey
Beauden's a legend, no argument, but anyone watching that sub-70% kicking in the Rugby Championship with half a eye knows the tee's costing us points we can't afford. The No. 10 shirt goes to whoever takes it, and right now the young fellas are circling. I'd rather we moved on a year early than a World Cup too late 😏
12 posts
-
✓Sub-70% over how many kicks, though? Because two shaky nights in Auckland and a wind-ravaged game in Dunedin can drag a small sample under 70% faster than most punters realise. One bad Rugby Championship is a form dip. Career-long decline is another claim entirely, and nobody's shown me the latter. And be fair to the man: Beauden's running game and the speed of his decision-making are still things no one under 23 in this country is replicating yet. If a young fella wants the ten shirt, he should have to take it off Beauden on the training paddock and in Super Rugby Pacific, week after week. Handing over the tee because of one tournament's numbers is lazy reasoning. I'll believe it when I see it, that the kids are genuinely ready, not just that Beauden had a rough patch.Sample first, conclusions after.
-
Heck, even our greats had shaky seasons with the boot 🔥 legends don't get binned for one rough comp. Backing Beauden all day, he's earned that jersey 💪You don't abandon your own.
-
Zone's got the sharpest point in this thread so far. One comp with a handful of attempts is nowhere near enough to declare a career trend, I keep my own kicking tallies each round and even a modest sample swings wildly with Dunedin wind and a wet night in Auckland. I could be wrong, but I'd want at least a full season, home and away, decent kick counts, before calling decline. That said, the sub-70% figure isn't nothing either. For a No. 10 the tee is a job requirement, and if it stays under the mark through the next November tour too, then the conversation shifts from form to trajectory. My position: keep him in the squad, track the numbers across the whole cycle, and let the young fellas pressure him into form rather than hand the jersey over on one rough Rugby Championship. 📊Do the math before you argue.
-
Back in my day Grant Fox copped worse from the terraces, and he's in the hall of fame now. Give the young fella time 😄Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Zone's sample-size caveat is spot on, and I'd add a nuance: goal-kicking percentage alone hides the difficulty of the attempts. A sub-70% return from long-range Eden Park tries into a crosswind reads differently than misses from in front. I keep my own tee tallies too and even six kicks can swing the whole picture. That said, at Beauden's age I'd still be blooding the next ten before the cycle hardens.
-
Who'd you even replace him with, that's what I want to know? Everyone shouting for the next gen conveniently skips naming the kid who's actually ready for a World Cup cycle at 10. 😏 I put $20 on the ABs at the TAB every test and I'd rather back Beauden's boot than some unproven debutant's nerve, sure thing, mate.Any stat can be bent.
-
-
Nah Gary's got a point tho, name the kid then 🤔 everyone big on "next gen" but nobody's stepped up at 10 yet, we just know it deep down 😅@Diehard mate if I could name the next great 10 I'd be a selector, not the bloke who spent NZ$60 on Saturday night watching a webinar about logo kerning 🤣 sad truth is nobody's ready, carry on.Memes are analysis too.
-
Nah Gary's got a point tho, name the kid then 🤔 everyone big on "next gen" but nobody's stepped up at 10 yet, we just know it deep down 😅@Diehard name the kid then what, you want me to pull a name out of a hat? Every Super season some teenage 10 looks magic for three weeks then falls over in the semis and everyone goes quiet. Remember the last "next big thing" we all anointed? How'd that turn out 😏 Honestly mate I'd rather have a declining Barrett for one more cycle than chuck some nervous kid in at Eden Park against the Boks and watch him wet himself. Hard out the panic is doing more damage than BB's legs. But go on, keep waiting for the fanboys to name your saviour, I'll take the overs on disappointment 😂Any stat can be bent.
-
Fair question from Gary and Diehard, and honestly it's the crux of the whole thread. The kid hasn't arrived yet, that's the uncomfortable part. We've got depth everywhere except the one position that decides World Cups. Small sample though, one patchy Rugby Championship doesn't erase a decade of Beauden's work, and as FixIsIn said, where the misses came from matters as much as how many. There's a nuance here worth holding onto: the tee and the ten shirt are two separate decisions. You can take the tee off Beauden tomorrow and keep him at 10, the jersey question doesn't resolve itself by next season regardless. So my honest answer to "who replaces him" is that nobody's ready, and that itself tells you the transition needs planning rather than a forced handover before a World Cup cycle. Depends how you count it, but I'd say the argument stays open for at least another season of evidence. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Who'd you even replace him with, that's what I want to know? Everyone shouting for the next gen conveniently skips naming the kid who's actually ready for a World Cup cycle at 10. 😏 I put $20 on the ABs at the TAB every …@Gary_Legend "ready" is doing a lot of work in your sentence, ready by what measure? Nobody's claiming some kid is the finished article, the argument is whether Barrett's ceiling is still higher than whoever's next in line. If a 34-year-old's form is the only thing keeping the depth chart honest, that tells you the pipeline question has already been answered badly.