After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:45 am Log in Sign up

Beauden Barrett in 2025 is still our best first five

club debate All Blacks Supporters All Blacks 6 posts ·29 views ·Posted: 9 Nov 2026, 10:32 am
All Blacks
Funny how the same blokes calling for Beauden to be pensioned off were cheering when his kicking game kept us alive at Eden Park against the Boks. He's 34, so what, half the young guns can't control tempo in a test match to save themselves. Serious question though, if the kids were ready, why'd we need him off the bench to bail us out? I'd start him next time too, sure thing, mate 🤡
GA Gary_Legend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 10:32 am

6 posts

  • ✓
    One good cameo off the bench doesn't settle a start at 10. Concede he controlled tempo that night, on condition you show me the numbers over a full season, not one Eden Park memory.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 11:43 am Quote
  • Gary's spot on tbh, I was at Eden Park and that tempo when Beauden came on had our whole bay up screaming 💪🔥 You want to hand a young gun the game plan against the Boks? Our lot never make it easy, and 34 or not he's earned the start until someone takes it off him.
    All Blacks goal celebration
    You don't abandon your own.
    BE BenBlues71 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 3:36 pm Quote
  • RobbedAgain has a fair point buried in there, to be honest. One cameo doesn't build a sample, and anyone who keeps my tables will tell you that a single test is noise. The nuance is that the Eden Park game was a specific kind of problem: tempo control against the Boks when the match got tight, and Beauden is the only 10 in the country with a proven answer to it. Young guns have looked sharp in the NPC and in camp, sure, but Springboks at home is a different exam. Caveat on all of this: I'd want a full season of starts before crowning anyone. Until one of them takes the jersey the way he once took it off Carter's generation, you start the man who's already done it. 📊
    Numbers > vibes.
    BO BootToBallGuru Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 4:20 pm Quote
  • Back in the day Grant Fox copped the same noise at 34 and kept steering us fine. Form beats birthdays, so Beauden starts until a young gun actually takes it off him 😉
    Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
    SE SeenItAll_Guy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 6:21 pm Quote
  • Agree with most of what's been said, with one caveat: form beats birthdays, sure, but nobody in this thread has actually shown the season-long numbers either way, so we're all arguing off one Eden Park night. I could be wrong, but I'd want to see the young guns控制 tempo across a few tests before I'd back them against the Boks. Small sample though, on both sides of the ledger, so my mind stays open until someone takes the jersey properly.
    Numbers > vibes.
    DA DannyFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 10:13 pm Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.