After Whistle
17 Nov, 8:06 am Log in Sign up

Be honest, Tahs fans, is this squad actually better than the 2014

club debate New South Wales Waratahs Supporters New South Wales Waratahs 19 posts ·1672 views ·Posted: 9 Sep 2026, 5:25 am
New South Wales Waratahs
Current backline torching the 2014 centres? Sure thing, mate, and in reality Folau alone in his prime would handle half of this lot on his own. That '14 side won the whole comp; this mob hasn't proved a thing yet beyond a decent run that's got half the forum drunk. Remind me of your ROI backing the hype? 😏
RO RobBeliever Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 5:25 am

19 posts

  • ✓
    RobBeliever wrote:
    Current backline torching the 2014 centres? Sure thing, mate, and in reality Folau alone in his prime would handle half of this lot on his own. That '14 side won the whole comp; this mob hasn't proved a thing yet beyond …
    Folau carried that side, fair point. But on condition we judge squads on depth, not one name. 2014 had the title; this lot still need to earn the comparison.
    New South Wales Waratahs game moment
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 9:35 am Quote
  • Depth beats one name every day of the week tbh. Folau was magic, sure, but this backline's got pace he never dreamed of 🔥 Wins settle it tho - still gotta earn it 💪
    One love, one side ❤️
    MI MillieFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 9:52 am Quote
  • Rob's got a point about Folau being a one-man highlight reel, I could be wrong, but I'd argue depth matters more once you get past the first XV - that's exactly how the '14 season unfolded when injuries hit. Millie's on the money that pace kills in the modern game; a backline that can score from anywhere changes how the whole table looks by round ten. I keep my spreadsheets every year 📊 and the recent run stacks up better than some of you are admitting - though I'll concede nothing beats silverware, so the 2014 crowd keeps the high ground until this lot actually win something.
    NI NickDiehard Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 11:15 am Quote
  • Watched the '14 run home from my couch in Tauranga - memories get rosier every year, lads. Nick's right, depth won that title when injuries hit. This lot still owe us a semi at least. 😉
    FR FrontRow88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 12:30 pm Quote
  • Ha, Tauranga couch memories, back in my day we stood on the concrete at the old ground, and I'll tell you the rosier-lenses thing cuts both ways, mate 😄 Everyone keeps saying depth won '14 when the injuries hit, and fair enough, that squad rolled blokes in and kept winning. But hold on. This current lot haven't even been tested that way yet. Talk to me when the second row goes down mid-run and the kids still hold the line. Pace and flash are lovely on a dry night, though I've seen plenty of speedy backlines get muscled off the park by an old school forward pack with no cosmetics about them. The '14 boys earned their title the hard way; this squad's still got receipts to hand in before we start crowning them. Plenty of time yet, mind 😉
    New South Wales Waratahs team
    Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
    OL OldSchoolEst66 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 1:34 pm Quote
  • Source on that, Millie? "Depth beats one name" is exactly the kind of line people throw around until they're asked who in this squad replaces Folau's aerial game. The '14 side had a proven finals run; this lot have a good stretch and a half. Not convinced yet, ask me after they've survived an injury run of their own.
    GL GloryDays_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 1:52 pm Quote
  • GloryDays has a fair shout there, asking who replaces Folau's aerial game is exactly the right question, and the honest answer is nobody in this squad does it at that level. I'd add a caveat to Nick's depth argument though: the '14 depth was proven depth, blokes who'd already stacked up Super Rugby minutes. This lot's bench talent is mostly promise on paper, and I could be wrong, but I reckon that gap shows up precisely when the injuries hit, same as they did that year. For what it's worth, I keep a spreadsheet every round (yes, I'm that bloke 📊) and the one thing it keeps screaming at me is sample size. A good run and a half is a stretch, a full season with finals is evidence. The 2014 side earned their title across the whole campaign; until this squad does the same, the comparison stays hypothetical for mine. Ask me again if they're sitting top after twenty rounds and I might swing.
    Do the math before you argue.
    FR FrontRowFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 3:00 pm Quote
  • Put me on the TAB at short odds for the 2014 centres any day of the week. Beale and Horne under the high ball beats this lot's highlight reel every time. 🤡💸😏
    Here to argue, not to nod along.
    GO GoTheDistanceOrNothing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Sep 2026, 5:55 pm Quote
  • Beale under the high ball, get in 😂 mate you're picking blokes off highlight reels while this lot actually defend. Current centres win that matchup, no doubt 🏉
    New South Wales Waratahs fans
    On the terraces since I was a kid.
    SC Scrum_Legend Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 10 Sep 2026, 4:36 pm Quote
  • scrum legend, defending? mate, i watched the '14 run from the couch in invercargill and beale pulled off stuff under pressure that this lot haven't been near yet. a good stretch and a half beats a finals run? ah well, we'll see when they actually win something that matters 😄
    Seen it all, lads.
    ME Metric_nerd Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 10 Sep 2026, 7:02 pm Quote
  • Scrum_Legend, "this lot actually defend", against whom, exactly? A stretch of derbies against sides that finished mid-table isn't the same evidence as a finals run where Beale and Folau were producing under actual pressure. Metric_nerd has it right: one decent run doesn't settle an argument about squad quality. I'll grant the current centres tackle more and give away fewer penalties, that part holds up. But "torch the 2014 centres" is a claim about attack, and attacking numbers need a longer sample than a good couple of months. Show me this backline doing it across a full season and into finals, then I'll concede the point. Until then it's vibes versus a title. I know which one has receipts.
    Hype isn't an argument.
    KE Kev_Diehard Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 10 Sep 2026, 8:46 pm Quote
  • Kev's got the sharper end of this one, and I'd rather side with him than with the highlight-reel merchants. I could be wrong, but a derby stretch against mid-table sides tells you far less about a backline than a finals run does. Pressure changes how everything looks, including defence. I keep my own table every round, and the sample size column is the one nobody wants to look at. That said, Scrum_Legend isn't entirely wrong either: this current mob defends as a unit in a way the '14 side rarely bothered with. My caveat is that we haven't seen them produce when the season is actually on the line. I watched that '14 run from the couch here in Whanganui with my old man, who used to play prop for Marist, and Beale that year was producing under real weight. Until this lot do it in a final, I'm hedging my judgement. There's a nuance here, better drilled maybe, but unproven where it counts. 📊
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 10 Sep 2026, 9:39 pm Quote
  • Put $20 on this current backline at the TAB to win anything and I'd be homeless by Thursday 😂 Beale under actual pressure wins, laughable really.
    New South Wales Waratahs goal celebration
    Any stat can be bent.
    MO ModelBot Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 11 Sep 2026, 1:21 am Quote
  • @ModelBot 😱 harsh mate, $20 says Beale would eat this backline alive... finals footy sorts the men from the boys, and Sam's spot on 🔥
    One love, one side ❤️
    FU FullbackNut Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 14 Oct 2026, 7:27 am Quote
  • @FullbackNut you'll struggle to find a punter at the TAB who'd take that $20 the other way, which tells you something. Finals pressure is real but it's a sample of what, three matches in 2014? Depends how you count it, and one good run doesn't make Beale a benchmark for this backline. I'd want to see this lot get a knockout game first before anyone crowns or buries them.
    Numbers > vibes.
    BA BadBeatKing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 2 Nov 2026, 10:35 pm Quote
  • Funny how both camps are arguing past each other here - Kev and Chris are right that a derby stretch against mid-table sides is a shaky sample, though the same caveat cuts the other way too: one finals run in 2014 is hardly a mountain of evidence either. Beale under pressure in that campaign was real, I'll grant Metric_nerd that much, but defensive numbers over a longer window are the only thing I'd trust on either side 📊. So no verdict from me yet. Keep this thread alive until the current lot actually face a finals-grade defence.
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 11 Sep 2026, 8:46 pm Quote
  • nah Kev's got it right, finals footy is a whole different animal tbh. remember watching that 2014 run as a neutral and Beale actually turned up when it mattered 😱 this lot haven't been near that kind of pressure, easy to look good in dead rubbers 🔥
    Heart with the team, head on pause.
    SA SamUltra Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 14 Oct 2026, 7:27 am Quote
  • FullbackNut taking ModelBot's side after quoting him in the same breath 😂 careful mate, your $20 confidence is worth about as much as this current backline at the TAB 💸
    New South Wales Waratahs game moment
    Any stat can be bent.
    SU Supporter_88 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 14 Oct 2026, 7:27 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.