After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:49 am Log in Sign up

Be honest, Tahs family: is our attacking flair just masking a forward

club debate New South Wales Waratahs Supporters New South Wales Waratahs 16 posts ·95 views ·Posted: 22 Sep 2026, 4:13 pm
New South Wales Waratahs
Flair's lovely on a Friday night, sure, but I've sat through enough derbies at Allianz to know the script. Every big night the scrum folds like a deck chair, refs march us backwards, and suddenly we're living off broken-field magic to mask a pack that's being shoved off the park. Even the punter next to me stopped checking his TAB multi and just started groaning every time we packed down. Fun trick for the doubters: count the scrum penalties we conceded across the last three derby matches and tell me that forward pack isn't getting bullied. You can't coach your way out of that with pretty backline plays. 🤡 And in reality? When the tackle contest turns into a war, who's fronting up for us? Exactly.
RO RobbedAgainMerchant Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 4:13 pm

16 posts

  • ✓
    RobbedAgainMerchant wrote:
    Flair's lovely on a Friday night, sure, but I've sat through enough derbies at Allianz to know the script. Every big night the scrum folds like a deck chair, refs march us backwards, and suddenly we're living off broken-…
    "Folded like a deck chair" is doing a lot of work in your post, considering you haven't cited a single scrum count. Sounds good, but show me the numbers, which derbies, which referee, how many penalties actually went against us at set-piece? I watched those matches too and my recollection is we conceded some, won some, and the real damage came from the collision area after 55 minutes when the bench hit. On condition that someone actually tallies those three derby scrum penalties and it turns out we're bleeding five-plus a night, I'll happily join the doom. Until then I'll keep my view that the pack is young and getting shoved around in patches, which is a fixable problem, rather than "bullied every big night", which is just a vibe dressed up as analysis.
    New South Wales Waratahs goal celebration
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 5:17 pm Quote
  • Nah I'm not sitting here with a referee's whistle and a notebook, what I've got is two eyes and a memory full of Friday nights where the scrum creaked and we still found a way 🔥 Flair doesn't happen by accident, fellas, someone's winning quick ball to let the backs fly. Fix the set-piece, sure, but stop acting like the magic isn't EARNED 💪🙌
    In the stands since I was a kid.
    UN UncleAllDay Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 6:43 pm Quote
  • Fair challenge from RobbedAgainHater318, but I'd side with UncleAllDay here. You can't mask a bullied pack with quick ball, because quick ball only exists if the forwards are securing the collision and holding the carry depth. I could be wrong, but the eye test says our backs get those attacking chances precisely because someone up front is winning the contact area, even on nights the scrum creaks 📊 Context matters though: the derby scrum penalties against us are real and worth tracking, I just wouldn't conclude the whole pack is soft off three bad set-piece nights.
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 6:53 pm Quote
  • ChrisDiehard's got it right I reckon. Back in my day the Tahs pack took some hiding at the old Sydney Football Stadium too, but the good sides always won the collision first and the magic came after. No secret there. Watch as long as I have and you'll get it: when the scrum creaks, even the prettiest backline starts living on scraps 😉
    Been here longer than some have followed.
    UN UnderdogNightmare Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 22 Sep 2026, 9:38 pm Quote
  • UncleAllDay, memory's fine until you ask why our halfback box-kicks off first phase every derby
    New South Wales Waratahs stadium
    Sample first, conclusions after.
    RO RobReds Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 12:07 am Quote
  • ChrisDiehard, that's the cleanest framing I've seen in this thread - quick ball is downstream of the collision, and anyone who's tracked it properly knows it. I keep my own carry-depth notes every round, and the derbies where the pack held the contact even in the first half, the backs looked like superstars. The nuance though: three derby matches is a small sample, and one of those nights we conceded scrum penalties to a side that wins them against everyone, so some of it is opposition quality, not just our pack folding. Where RobbedAgainMerchant does have a point is the pattern repeating on big nights specifically - I'd want five or six derbies before calling it structural. Still, box-kicking off first phase like RobReds flagged? That's a tactic chosen under pressure, and pressure usually starts up front. 📊
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 2:22 am Quote
  • RobbedAgainMerchant whinged about the pack folding so let's just take that as gospel apparently 😂 FixIsInPTSD getting fanboyed by the whole thread for one line of common sense, wild. Me, I'll take the over on broken-field magic every time. As a punter I'd rather have a Tahs side that wins ugly derbies through broken play than a "proper" pack that loses them in the scrum anyway. Fancy getting monstered AND playing crashball attrition? That's a losing multi on the TAB every week. Quick ball's the mask, sure. But plenty of masks still collect the four points. 😏
    Any stat can be bent.
    BA BadBeatAndy Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 5:29 pm Quote
  • BadBeatAndy I rate that but nah mate, folded scrum kills everything, quick ball aint happening off your arse 😱 backs can't magic up front-foot footy, come on 🔥
    You don't abandon your own.
    FI FixIsInDenier540 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 6:38 pm Quote
  • BadBeatAndy mate, been watching this game since before it went professional and i've seen worse packs than ours look world-beaters when the halves got a roll on, remember how the crusaders used to win derbies with not much of a scrum either? ah well, we'll see come the next derby night at allianz, might even be worth the seat price 😄
    New South Wales Waratahs game moment
    Seen it all, lads.
    ME Metric_nerd Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 23 Sep 2026, 7:17 pm Quote
  • @Metric_nerd go easy on me if this is daft, but does the halved scrum thing cut both ways then? Like if our halves get front foot ball and still go quiet in derbies, does that point back to the pack anyway? Still wrapping my head around how much set piece actually drives attack 😅
    New South Wales Waratahs team
    Learn something new every day.
    RE RefBlindNightmare864 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 27 Oct 2026, 2:43 am Quote
  • Metric_nerd, source on the Crusaders winning derbies with a weak scrum? Pretty sure their scrum was doing plenty of the bullying when it mattered.
    GL GloryDays_4Life Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 12:58 pm Quote
  • FixIsInDenier540 has it right - no front foot, no magic, simple as that. I could be wrong, but I'd add a caveat: our lineout maul has quietly been decent on some of those big nights, so the pack isn't uniformly bullied. Still, I mark the scrum penalties in my notebook every round and the trend against the Brumbies and Reds derbies is ugly to look at. Watched one of them from the cheap seats and it hurt just the same.
    Do the math before you argue.
    FR FrontRowFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 3:12 pm Quote
  • There's a nuance here that both camps keep missing: the scrum penalties in those derbies and the maul work FrontRowFan mentions can both be true at once, it just depends how you count it, set-piece discipline is one column, collisions and maul momentum are another. My spreadsheet has them as separate lines for a reason 📊 Which one actually decides a big night? That's the part I still can't settle, so I'm keeping the argument open.
    Numbers > vibes.
    BA BadBeatKing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 4:24 pm Quote
  • Nice of the fanboys to discover nuance the second their scrum gets called out 😏 RefBlindNightmare864, your instinct's right though. Give the halves clean ball all night and they still go missing up here, that tells you the pack's getting shoveled. Flair's easy when the forwards hand it to you on a plate. Laughable really 🤡
    Here to argue, not to nod along.
    GO GoTheDistanceOrNothing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 27 Oct 2026, 2:43 am Quote
  • @GoTheDistanceOrNothing the provocation is half fair, but the logic has a hole in it. Clean front foot ball doesn't guarantee anything if the support carry and first receiver options stay predictable, and that's a coaching/skill question, not purely a pack one. Front foot ball against a set drift defence that knows what's coming still dies quietly. I could be wrong, but my read from watching those derby halves is that the Tahs get decent enough attacking platforms and then waste them in the 10-12 channel, choices and depth as much as delivery. Compare their tries off turnover ball against their tries off structured phases and the contrast tells you something about both areas honestly. RefBlindNightmare864's instinct is worth following though, because if the halves go quiet even WITH clean ball, you've got to ask whether the pack is still being monstered at the second-man contact level, which never shows up in scrum stats. Small sample across a few derbies, mind. 📊
    Numbers > vibes.
    DA DannyFaithful Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 2:00 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.