With no league table to hide behind
Funny thing about Test windows, there's nowhere to park a bad month. In a competition you can drop a stinker and still sit third on the table and everyone shrugs. In Tests the loss just sits there in the record for years, and the pecking order talk radio and the pubs run off moves immediately.
I could be wrong, but I reckon the sides with the most stored goodwill are the ones with furthest to fall. Reputation is a lagging indicator, it takes three or four poor results before the general public actually reprices a team, and a window with no table softens nothing. My own rule when I keep the spreadsheets is you judge a Test side on its last six tests, full stop, because context matters and a tour that looked fine on paper can hide a lot. Which side do you all think is one bad result away from the penny dropping?
6 posts
-
✓England tbh, they've always got hype built up and one bad window and the talking heads gut them for years 😱 us ABs copping a loss hurts but everyone expects it, we're the measuring stick 🤬 nothing softens it though, no table to hide behind so every defeat just sits there. Back us all the way regardless 💪🔥
-
hard to look past England agreeing with MaulFaithful, though I'd add Wales to the mix. back in my day they were everyone's favourite giant-killers and now a bad window just gets shrugged off. watch as long as I have and you'll get it: reputation in Tests is earned over decades and lost in one November, and no table to lean on when it happens 😉
-
hard to look past England agreeing with MaulFaithful, though I'd add Wales to the mix. back in my day they were everyone's favourite giant-killers and now a bad window just gets shrugged off. watch as long as I have and …Funny you bring up Wales getting shrugged off, because that's exactly why I don't buy the pecking order panic. A mid-season table lies anyway, fixtures differ, form is noise. At least in Tests everyone plays a similar slate in a window, so England dropping one actually means something. Wales falling quietly? That already happened years ago, nobody's bracing for anything.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
RobbedAgainHater318 has a point worth digging a bit deeper into, even though I usually side with the fixtures argument. In a window the slate really is roughly comparable, so the "everyone plays everyone" defence loses most of its power. That's why I keep a running sheet each November and each July: once a side drops two or three Tests in one window, the ranking computers and the punter chatter both move fast, and there's no mid-table cushion to land on. On who falls furthest, I'd frame it like this. England carry the biggest built-in hype, so their margin for error is thinnest. Wales are arguably worse off in real terms, because their fall has already happened and a poor window just confirms it, nobody prices them high anymore. The All Blacks sit in a strange middle spot, we get punished harder than anyone for one loss precisely because of the Eden Park aura and the measuring-stick tag.Do the math before you argue.
-
Funny how the old Eden Park nights taught me one thing, a reputation is earned over years and lost in one long afternoon. England still takes the biggest tumble for mine, all that build-up before every window and nowhere to hide when it goes sideways. Wales are a different sort of sad, more of a slow slide everyone's stopped arguing about. RobbedAgainHater318 has a point that a clean slate in a window tells you something a mid-season table doesn't, and TaurangaBro is right that the fixtures excuse wears thin in November. But one window is still just one window, the pecking order doesn't get rewritten in a month, it gets nudged. Ask me again after the full season and I'll give you a proper verdict. Young fellas in this thread are learning fast though, I'll give you that 😄Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.