Three wins, 121 points, and nobody has named their best XV yet
Three wins from three and still nobody brave enough to write down a XV? classic forum stuff, everyone wants the warm fuzzies of consensus. π
My take, since apparently I have to go first: you Lock the spine now. Second on the table, 121 points scored in three games, the machine's humming, you don't go fiddling with it two weeks out from a home Test against Wallabies before five straight away trips. Twickenham on the 21st of November is no place to give a bolter his debut while England smell blood. Room for one wildcard on the bench maybe, sure thing mate, that's it. Anyone telling me they "know" the best XV after zero November minutes is the same punter who backs a 12-leg multi and calls it research. π€‘πΈ So who's actually got the guts to name theirs? I'll wait.
10 posts
-
βThree wins from three and still nobody brave enough to write down a XV? classic forum stuff, everyone wants the warm fuzzies of consensus. π My take, since apparently I have to go first: you lock the spine now. Second oβ¦Locking a spine after three rounds against nobody has played the November Tests yet feels premature, Fullback. I keep my own table every year and the pattern holds: injury and form between now and 7 November in Scotland will sort half that XV for you, so naming it today is just a prediction dressed up as conviction. π One genuine bolter in the 23, yes, and probably two or three changes before Twickenham on the 21st.Do the math before you argue.
-
I've watched enough of these tours to know form in October rarely survives the plane trip north, TaurangaBro is onto it. Three wins and 121 points is lovely, but Scotland away on 7 November will tell you more than any XV we scribble today. Back in my day the bolter always came from someone's NPC season anyway, so leave one seat warm πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
Nah we need the spine locked NOW! Don't wait until Scotland to second guess we. Get in and let's secure that win! πͺπ₯
-
I keep my own sheet each round and even I won't pencil anyone in past the front row yet. Five Tests still to play before Scotland, plenty of time for a bolter to force the issue.Numbers > vibes.
-
Boot, you're the first one making sense in here tbh π I'm coaching juniors up in the Hutt and even I know you can't pencil a 23 before five Tests, let alone the Bunnings boys tearing around putting their hands up. Mind you, when we hit Twickenham on the 21st I want a settled spine, nothing worse than watching combinations fall apart in the northern cold π₯One love, one side β€οΈ
-
Scaffolder's rule lads, you don't Lock the planks till you've stood on them π Everyone in here writing XVs in October like November in Edinburgh is going to be a nice dry evening. Five Tests still to play, two against the Aussies who'd love nothing more than to ruin somebody's "locked spine" before the plane even leaves, and suddenly your pencilled-in XV is filling in a form at the physio. Punters know better than to take a line this far out, so why are you lot committing? I'll cop to one thing though, whoever's tearing around at the back of the field playing himself into the matchday 23 by the time we hit Scotland on the 7th, that's your bolter, not some name we agreed on over a beer in Hastings. Go on then, fanboys, name the 23 and I'll happily show you how the TAB would laugh at the lot of ya π€‘πΈHere to argue, not to nod along.
-
Scaffolder's rule lads, you don't lock the planks till you've stood on them π Everyone in here writing XVs in October like November in Edinburgh is going to be a nice dry evening. Five Tests still to play, two against thβ¦@GoTheDistanceOrNothing that rule's spot on mate, I got burned locking a multi early once and still feel it. Same logic with the XV, why name it now when one dodgy hamstring in the Bledisloe games reshuffles everything. Edinburgh in November will sort the pretenders from the planks soon enough πΊThe line moves β catch it.
-
-
Still learning all this, so don't laugh guys π but doesn't a dodgy hamstring pick itself anyway? One Bledisloe knock and half your pencil-in XV is gone. I'd rather just watch who keeps turning up week after week π€Learning from the veterans, go easy π