Right now, today: who's our next world-class centre
Chur lads, word is there's been a quiet look across the ditch at a certain ball-playing 12 who distributes like a five-eighth and actually tackles - no names from me yet, don't want to jinx it 😏. But imagine a proper playmaker at inside centre with a genuine line-breaker outside him? Would fix the midfield mess overnight, surely.
16 posts
-
✓A mate of a mate heard something, is that where we're at now? Rob, "no names" and "word is" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in that post. Which comp, which club, which player, give me one actual detail and I'll take it seriously. Because here's my problem: every quiet look across the ditch turns out to be a bloke who had two good games in a Super Rugby derby and a highlight reel doing the rounds. Playmaker at 12 is the right idea, I've said that for ages - distribution, defensive reads, a proper second axis. But "distributes like a five-eighth and actually tackles" describes about six players until you name one. Source on that? Otherwise this is a vibe dressed up as intel, and I don't pick a World Cup midfield on vibes.
-
Nah GloryDays relax, Rob's not writing a police report 😂 even if the name never comes out, the idea itself is the whole point. Who's gonna argue we don't need a genuine distributor at 12? Watch the last few tests, every time we get slow ball at second five the whole backline goes sideways and we're back to crash-and-hope. A ball-playing 12 with a proper 13 outside him? That's how you get Jordie and the wings into space 🔥 Played against a bloke like that in club footy years back, just one subtle pass at the line and suddenly your 13's through a hole you didn't even see. That's what we're missing tbh. And on defence he actually tackles, so no more praying he holds up in contact 🙌 backing them all day if the selectors go this way, we've got the athletes outside, just give them a brain at 12 💪You don't abandon your own.
-
I could be wrong, but a cross-ditch poach of a ball-playing 12 feels like a long shot to me. Rugby AU contracts, that mob's depth chart and the eligibility wars make it a nightmare, and we've been burned on those rumours before. The idea is spot on though 📊. Honestly I'd rather we groom one through the Bunnings NPC and Super Rugby pathway than chase someone else's finished product at 12.Do the math before you argue.
-
Rob dropping "no names" gossip like he's got sources inside the union 😂 I'd put real money down a TAB multi before that signing ever happens, GloryDays. And in reality?Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
FrontRowFan's got the eligibility mess right, and I'd add the caveat that even a signed poach needs two years of game time here before we call him world-class. Show me the numbers first.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
I coached juniors last season and the best kid in the midfield was the smallest fella on the park — all he did was put others through gaps 🔥 That's what we're missing lads, a genuine playmaker who can put Beaudy's runners away, not another lump running straight into two defenders 😱 Memory of our lot never making it easy in the middle third, we've needed a distribution 12 since forever tbh 💪Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
Sam, your junior story actually backs my point better than you'd think. A wee caveat though: one small fella at under-12s is a sample size of precisely one kid, so let's not build a Test midfield on it 📊. What I'd push back on with the others is the "crash runner" straw man. The blokes we've tried since the last cycle weren't failing because they ran hard - plenty put up solid metres per carry - they were failing because nobody outside them saw clean ball on the front foot. Compare carry stats to try assists and the gap tells you everything. And FrontRowFan, I'd temper your pessimism slightly: the eligibility mess is real, but if a ball-playing 12 genuinely exists across the ditch and the union rates him, they've moved mountains for less. Two years of game time before we judge him? Fair, though the distribution shows up in six months, not six Tests.
-
fix, seen worse arguments than yours but that caveat misses the point a bit 😄 one kid at under-12s, sure, but back in my day the great midfields were all built on distribution first — second five who could pass off both hands and suddenly the whole backline hums. give me a playmaker who can defend over another lump every day of the week, we've had enough crash runners filling the 12 jersey to last us a decade.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
fix, seen worse arguments than yours but that caveat misses the point a bit 😄 one kid at under-12s, sure, but back in my day the great midfields were all built on distribution first — second five who could pass off both …@UnderdogNightmare distribution first, fine, but define "world-class". Passing off both hands or winning collisions at test level? Pick one, because they're rarely the same kid.
-
@OffsideKing_Gate don't laugh but this is the bit I keep getting stuck on too 😅 why can't a kid be both though? Feels like at school level the good passers dodge contact and the big boppers run straight over everyone, so nobody learns the other half. Is that just how it stays, or do coaches actually fix it somewhere along the way? 🤔Daft questions are my specialty.
-
@OffsideKing_Gate don't laugh but this is the bit I keep getting stuck on too 😅 why can't a kid be both though? Feels like at school level the good passers dodge contact and the big boppers run straight over everyone, so…@RideOrDie_247 nah you're onto something tbh. I coach the juniors and the big lads just get told "run hard" every week, nobody makes them pass 😅 takes a coach who'll actually demand both. We did contact-first drills with my second five this season and his distribution came on miles. Kids can be both, we just gotta make them 🔥You don't abandon your own.
-
@Beth_TillIDie contact-first drills actually working sounds good but got a question. One kid, one season, your own eyes on him. How do you scale that when half the club coaches still think a big second five passing is a bonus, not the job? Genuine question, because that gap is where the next test centre gets lost.Hype isn't an argument.
-
Watched club footy on the weekend and every try started with a 12 who passed first and ran later. Old heads like Underdog have it right 😏Here to argue, not to nod along.
-
ha, robbie that smell of "quiet look across the ditch" takes me back. we've had a few of those whispers over the years. Remember the big rumour about an aussie ten coming home just before the last world cup cycle? everyone at the club was certain, drinks were practically poured. never happened. and the one before that too, some promising lad who signed a nice deal over there and stayed put. paper talk has a funny way of evaporating once the chequebooks come out. that said, agree with the sentiment here - underdog and gothedistance have it right. back in the day the great all black midfields all had a second five who could pass off both hands and read a defence. the lump running straight into two blokes was always the easy option, and it never won us anything. so aye, a proper playmaker for the 12 jersey, whoever he is and wherever he comes from. time will tell though, eh. ah well, we'll see.Seen it all, lads.
-
Sam, your junior story actually backs my point better than you'd think. A wee caveat though: one small fella at under-12s is a sample size of precisely one kid, so let's not build a Test midfield on it 📊. What I'd push b…@Metric_nerd ha that ten rumour was everywhere, whole club seemed convinced 😅 same with every "quiet look", half of them never even get to a press conference. tbh I'd rather we back our own juniors anyway... feed them game time and see who bites 💪You don't abandon your own.