Honest question, fam: is Beauden Barrett actually our best first
Anyone actually watching Plummer kick above 85% at Eden Park this season and still picking Beauden on name value needs their head read. He's been shunted to fullback twice already, that tells you everything about where the selectors see him. Quarter-final? Plummer starts, easy, and I'd love to see the fanboys defend the opposite with a straight face. 😏
6 posts
-
✓Two starts at fullback doesn't automatically mean what you think it means. That could be injury cover or a tactical fit for a specific opposition, and until someone actually shows me the selection reasoning, "shunted" is doing a lot of heavy lifting in your post. On the 85% figure at Eden Park, what's the sample size? Six kicks? Eight? Kicking percentage on a small pile of attempts in friendly conditions tells me less about who I want with a quarter-final line on the line. Beauden's had years of big-moment tests, including the pressure ones. I'd still pick him, but I'll change my mind if anyone can show me Plummer's numbers under real pressure rather than a warm evening in front of his own crowd. Source on that being like-for-like?
-
Nah, I coached juniors with blokes who got shifted around all the time, doesn't mean they've lost the jersey 😤 Beauden at fullback is a luxury, he can cover there AND still start at 10 for a do-or-die quarter. Plummer's kicking at Eden Park has been magic, 85%+ is no joke, but finals footy is a different beast fam. JB for me, form picks itself 🙌🔥One love, one side ❤️
-
Millie's got it right, I could be wrong but Plummer's 85%+ at Eden Park is the stronger pick on paper, small sample though. Beauden covers 15 if needed.Numbers > vibes.
-
Seen a few of these ten debates in my time at Eden Park, going right back to the amateur days, and the answer was never just the goal-kicking column. Plummer's 85%+ there is real but it's a small sample, while Beauden has run quarter-finals before and covers 15 if things go sideways. Pick on the night's needs, I reckon, and trust the old head when it's do-or-die 😉Watch as long as I have and you'll get it.
-
Interesting how nobody's mentioned the wind at Eden Park yet, because that's half of Plummer's percentage right there. I've sat in the northern stand enough evenings to know how kind that ground can be to a kicker on a calm night, and I could be wrong, but I'd want to see his numbers away before anointing him. That said, my own spreadsheet has Beauden's two shifts to fullback logged as rotation rather than demotion, so the "shunted" framing doesn't hold for me either. Danny's point about the sample size is fair, and OldSchool's point about quarter-final experience is fairer still. Honestly the honest answer is we won't know until the team sheet drops, and anyone punting a TAB multi on this debate already knows how quickly selections can flip. Both cases have legs, which is probably why nobody's closed this argument yet, including me.Do the math before you argue.