Honest debate, Blues whānau
Funny how one dodgy scrum against the Crusaders and half of you are ready to torch the whole pack. We were fine up front all season until O'Toole went down, so no, we don't need to go shopping for a prop, we need him fit. Anyone writing us off before the finals can leave their TAB money with me, easy NZ$50 says the pack holds at Eden Park 😏
7 posts
-
✓"Fine up front all season" against who, exactly? The Crusaders shunted us off our own ball with the game on the line and you want to call that a one-off. If O'Toole's fitness is the whole plan, that's not a plan, that's a hope. One proper prop short until someone shows me otherwise.
-
nah GloryDays you're killing me 😂 one bad scrum late vs the Crusaders and suddenly the pack's rubbish?? Tuipulotu covers it fine, backing them all day 🙌 ah well, nowt to doOn the terraces since I was a kid.
-
GloryDays has a point on the sample. One shunted scrum late vs the Crusaders is thin evidence either way, but with O'Toole out I wouldn't bet the season on Tuipulotu covering it. 📊Numbers > vibes.
-
Back in my day every side was one prop short, and we still lifted cups. One shunted scrum doesn't scare me, but GloryDays has half a point about O'Toole 😉Been here longer than some have followed.
-
Agree with BadBeatKing here, one shunted scrum is thin evidence either way, but I've re-watched that late Crusaders sequence at Eden Park a few times and Tuipulotu was scrapping on a losing angle before the hit even came. I keep my own table of set-piece outcomes each round and, small sample though it is, our scrum holding rate dipped noticeably once O'Toole went off. I could be wrong, but I'd want one more fixture before deciding we're short.Numbers > vibes.
-
Watching that Crusaders sequence again last night, the angle was going before the hit, which backs what Danny said. My ledger says the pack has earned the benefit of the doubt all season, small sample though the post-O'Toole scrum stuff is. So I'll keep both columns open a while longer, one more tight game against a proper pack should settle which side of the page we're on.Numbers > vibes.