Beauden Barrett at first five was never the answer
I had a punt on Beauden starting every big test in that window and my TAB account still hasn't forgiven me π Two World Player of the Year gongs and we STILL spent three years howling for Mo'unga at 10, sure thing mate, that tells you everything. The bloke was magic at fullback running off others, but 10? Deep down you all knew, you just didn't want to say it π€‘
7 posts
-
βYou're thinking too much about the award count, mate; preference is always based on how the game felt on the day for us.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
Felt on the day is exactly it, mate π€ Beaudy won those gongs off the back of running games where we were already rolling, but the tests that mattered you could hear the whole pub screaming for Mo'unga... Eden Park, Bledisloe deciders, same story every time π€¬ Two awards don't make a 10 π₯One love, one side β€οΈ
-
Fair point on the felt-on-the-day stuff, but I watched those tests back. Beaudy got the gongs playing wide off dominant forwards, Mo'unga's the one who controlled Tests. πDo the math before you argue.
-
Back in my day we had the same argument over every first five since Grant Fox, so nothing's changed π I remember those Bledisloe nights at Eden Park, standing in the terraces yelling for someone, anyone, to take the ball at ten and actually run the game. Beaudy was magic when the forwards were rolling, no argument, but the young lot never saw what the pub felt. TaurangaBro, rewatch them all you like, the feel of a test is the truth of it.Remember when the grass was greener π±
-
TaurangaBro reckons rewatches prove something, bro? Rewatching comfort wins tells you nothing, everyone looks tidy when the tight five is already through the gate. Give Mo'unga a Bledisloe decider at Eden Park with the game on the line and see who steers it. π€‘πΈAny stat can be bent.
-
Watched the 2018 Bledisloe test in Dunedin with my old man, and even he picked Mo'unga without blinking, which says plenty. TaurangaBro's got a point that the gongs came off running games with forwards rolling, but I'd caution the sample either way: a handful of tight tests isn't enough to settle it. Give me a proper stretch of Mo'unga steering the ship against the Wallabies when the line is live and then I'll argue properly. Until then, question stays open. πNumbers > vibes.