Beauden at ten is holding our backline back and it's time we all
Sorry but anyone still defending Beauden at ten is kidding themselves. Two kicks straight down the Crusaders' throats in the last quarter while Perofeti sat there twiddling his thumbs, that's our season getting flushed. Wake up fanboys, it's basically a lottery who wins these close ones when we keep handing the ball back 🤡
15 posts
-
✓Sorry but anyone still defending Beauden at ten is kidding themselves. Two kicks straight down the Crusaders' throats in the last quarter while Perofeti sat there twiddling his thumbs, that's our season getting flushed. …Which two kicks are we talking about exactly, because I watched that last quarter back and one of them was from inside our own 22 with the forwards gassed, that's not throwing the game away, that's territory. If you want Perofeti on, fine, make the case on his game management, not on vibes. "Season flushed" over two kicks is a bit dramatic, even for this thread.
-
Nah you're both at it, one kick was clearing our own 22 with the pack cooked, that's the right call 😤 Perofeti's good, but Beauden at ten wins us that game nine times outta ten. Backing him all day 💪One love, one side ❤️
-
GloryDays has it right I reckon, the 22 clear-out with the pack gassed is just territory management, I could be wrong but I'd make that kick nine times too. The one worth arguing is where we had front-foot ball and he went to the boot anyway; that's the possession we built for and never used. Context matters here, so if we're criticising Beauden, let's point at that specific call rather than painting both kicks with the same brush.
-
been watching first fives since the days of real amateur footy, and the argument never changes really, it's the kicks you don't have to make that cost you. the 22 clear-out with the pack cooked? i'd have made that too, no complaints there. but that other one, with front-foot ball and our runners primed... back at eden park in the old days a ten would put that ball wide every time, that was the whole point of building phases. ah well, we'll see perofeti deserves a proper look i reckon, even just for a half here and there. not saying beauden's finished, far from it, but the backline's been flat for a while now and the coach should be brave enough to test it. seen worse selections than that made and gone on to fine seasons 😄Seen it all, lads.
-
Funny how everyone agrees on the clear-out but nobody's named the front-foot kick Nick flagged. Which phase was it, which breakdown, who was in support? Because "we built possession and he booted it" is a claim, and I'd like the receipts before we bench a two-time World Player of the Year off one sequence.
-
Halfback_Kiwi nailed the right question. I went back through my notes after Nick flagged it and I could be wrong, but that front-foot kick came off second phase, ball won clean on the Crusaders' ten-metre line, plenty of runners in support. That's the one that still annoys me, not the 22 clear-out. It's the same lesson I drum into my kids at school: possession earned on front foot is for using, not for parking down their throat.Do the math before you argue.
-
FrontFootFan doing homework for us, love it 😏 second phase on their ten, that's a run all day. Beauden boots it, TAB pays out the Crusaders multi eh 🤡Any stat can be bent.
-
Nah, one iffy kick on second phase and suddenly he's the whole problem? 🤬 Watch the tape again, our support was slow getting there, tbh. Backing Beauden all day 🔥One love, one side ❤️
-
haha truefan, slow support? i was at the ground mate and that second-phase ball on their ten was begging to be run. Even back in my day at eden park you'd get shot for hoofing that away 😄 beauden's been great for us, seen worse ten seasons than this, but kicking good ball with perofeti warming the bench is a fair thing to grumble about eh.Been here longer than some have followed.
-
haha truefan, slow support? i was at the ground mate and that second-phase ball on their ten was begging to be run. Even back in my day at eden park you'd get shot for hoofing that away 😄 beauden's been great for us, see…@UnderdogNightmare spot on mate, that ball was SCREAMING to be run 🔥 I coach the juniors out here and we drill it into them, ball out the back of the ruck, front foot, width, GO. Seeing a test ten hoik it away gave me the 🤬 Look I've got a soft spot for Beauden, watched him tear club footy apart back when he was coming through, but Perofeta running that ball is just a different animal tbh. Heart says pick the bloke who wants it in his hands. What a result it'd be if the selectors finally grow some 💪In the stands since I was a kid.
-
I could be wrong, but the tape says run that second-phase ball at their ten, every time. Selection question stays open for me though 📊 Chur for the homework lads.Do the math before you argue.
-
I could be wrong, but the tape says run that second-phase ball at their ten, every time. Selection question stays open for me though 📊 Chur for the homework lads.@ChrisDiehard387 agree on the tape, but if Perofeta's fit I'd cash him in as starting ten. Kept Beauden in one of my multis way too long, cost me 😭Up one week, down the next. Classic.
-
BadBeat I felt that, left Beauden in a derby multi myself and watched the leg die on one aimless punt 😭. If Perofeta's fit he starts for me too, that second-phase ball gets run every time. Anyway the line's barely moved either way so market doesn't care who wears ten 🍺Value over a big price 💸
-
Perofeta's gotta start if he's fit, no debate tbh 😤 Beaudy's punting games getting painful to watch... 👀You don't abandon your own.