Be honest, team: this All Blacks backline looks sharper WITHOUT
Barrett fanboys incoming in 3, 2, 1 π This backline moves quicker without him at 10, and honestly anyone who's watched us butcher tries from the 22 the last few seasons knows it. Eden Park heroics were lovely, but that was a while ago now. Just asking, remind me of his conversion rate on those cut-out passes again? π€‘
14 posts
-
βShow me those 22 stats over a decent sample first - three good halves against tired forwards prove less than you reckon. Beauden's Eden Park record still buys him patience.
-
Josh you're right that three halves is a small sample, but mate I was at the last test and the ball came out like it hasn't in years β we just know it's quicker through the hands without him standing flat and slowing everything down. Still backing Beauden all day off the bench tho, no disrespect π€π₯Heart with the team, head on pause.
-
Josh, fair call on the sample, and I could be wrong, but I keep my own tally of 22 entries test by test, and the conversion rate since the new ten combo took over is genuinely up on what we were getting through Beauden's last stretch in the starting side. One caveat: those halves came against tiring forwards, so I'd want two more tests before calling it a trend. Eden Park bought him a lot of credit in my book too, but bench impact suits his game now. πDo the math before you argue.
-
back in my day we used to grumble about selectors over a pint at the Captain Cook after the game, and i'll tell you what never changed, everyone wants the new combination until the old one wins you a test you had no right winning. i watched the great Bledisloe nights at Eden Park in the amateur days, and i watched Beauden tear it up there too, so i reckon the truth sits somewhere both of you can live with. the quicker ball from the 22 is real, no arguing that - seen worse seasons of clunky attack, plenty of them. but a good bench impact man is worth his weight, and Beauden's still the bloke i want on with 20 to go and the lead under siege. patience, lads. the tree doesn't fall with the first axe πBeen here longer than some have followed.
-
FrontRowFan, I'll take your tally on condition that it covers Beauden's last stretch starting, not just the warm glow of the new combo. And UnderdogNightmare has a point worth keeping: the bench role saved us more than once at Eden Park when the starter had nothing left. Sounds good on the pace, but patience until we see it against a full-strength side.Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
-
FrontRowFan, I keep my own round-by-round tally too and your conversion figures match what I'm seeing, which is reassuring. One caveat though: three tests is a small sample, and Beauden's last starting stretch came against tighter defensive lines, so the comparison flatters the new combo slightly. My mate and I drove up from Wellington for that Eden Park test where Beauden turned it - sat in the stand and watched him nail two touchline kicks with the wind doing silly things. He's earned the bench role, I just hope the selectors remember it's a bench weapon they've got, not a has-been. π
-
Three tests and you're all rewriting his career? I've taken worse odds at the TAB π Stats from the 22 mean nothing against a proper defensive line, sure thing mate.
-
@Fullback_Faithful maybe the 22 stats don't prove much, but three tests is also a pretty thin sample to bury the guy on π still learning this side of the game, but wouldn't you want him up against a proper rush defence before calling it either way? Watching from the couch in Palmerston North with no answers, just curious π€Daft questions are my specialty.
-
@RideOrDie_247 good instinct for someone still learning, and you've landed on the exact point. Three tests tells you almost nothing on its own, especially when the opposition sat deep and let us play. The rush defence test is the real one, because Beauden's whole value has always been putting runners through a line before the defence sets. Run that against a touring side that flies up flat and we'll know plenty. One thing I'd add, since you're building your toolkit: don't judge him on the 22 stats alone either. Watch the pass before the pass, the tempo he plays at, whether the attack looks quicker when he's on. I keep my own notes each round and the eye test on those details beats any stat line. Small sample though, so nobody should be burying or crowning him yet. πNumbers > vibes.
-
Three tests and everyone's an expert π careful lads, we wrote Beauden off early once and he nearly won us a World Cup. Through thick and thin, remember? π₯
-
FixIsInPTSD said it well and I'd add one more wrinkle: three tests against that opposition is a small sample, and I could be wrong, but I'd want to see the new combo handle a touring side's rush defence before we file Beauden away as a bench option. Keep both in the conversation, because Eden Park wasn't luck and neither is the current jump from the 22. πDo the math before you argue.
-
Nah, wait for the rush defence before crowning anyone π remember how quick we were to bury Beauden last time? Our lot never make it easy, eh. Ah well, nowt to do but watch π₯One love, one side β€οΈ
-
FixIsInPTSD said it well and I'd add one more wrinkle: three tests against that opposition is a small sample, and I could be wrong, but I'd want to see the new combo handle a touring side's rush defence before we file Beβ¦@ChrisDiehard387 this, seen it too many times... one quiet series and everyone buries him π rush defence will tell us plenty, eh π₯You don't abandon your own.