After Whistle
17 Nov, 7:28 am Log in Sign up

Be honest, Tahs family: is our backline actually world-class

club debate New South Wales Waratahs Supporters New South Wales Waratahs 10 posts ·86 views ·Posted: 24 Sep 2026, 4:04 am
New South Wales Waratahs
Electric against the Brumbies, sure thing mate, the Brumbies defended like a scaffolding crew after smoko. Once the Crusaders get their hands on that centre pairing we'll find out quick whether they're world-class or just lapping up soft touches. Any punter backing them at the TAB right now is getting touched on the line. 😏
GO GoTheDistanceOrNothing Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 4:04 am

10 posts

  • ✓
    Scaffolding crew after smoko, that's rich coming from someone predicting the Crusaders will do all the testing without naming a single tactic. The Brumbies actually defend well in the middle third, the pairing still punched through them twice. Happy to concede they might struggle against a rush defence like Christchurch's, on condition that you judge them after the derby itself and not off vibes beforehand. I'd keep both centres untouched at thirteen inside, shuffling them now would tell us less, not more.
    Sample first, conclusions after.
    RO RobReds Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 5:12 am Quote
  • 🙌 Through thick and thin with our centres, mates, they punched through the Brumbies' midfield twice and you just KNOW the Crusaders are gonna feel them too. GET IN! 🔥💪
    New South Wales Waratahs stadium
    UP UpsetKing_King Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 5:29 am Quote
  • I'll side with RobReds on this one, and I could be wrong, but the sample size argument GoTheDistance is running doesn't hold much water. The Brumbies have been one of the better defensive sides in the middle third all season, so punching through them twice is a genuine data point, you can't just wave it off by saying the defence was soft. There's a nuance here: what the Brumbies concede is one thing, what their structure actually forces centres to solve is another, and our pair solved it. Would I like to see them tested against the Crusaders before crowning them world-class? Absolutely, that's fair. But flattered by soft defence means the evidence should point the other way, and it doesn't. My thirteen stays as is for the derby. You don't reshuffle a midfield that's actually producing line breaks while the tape shows the right defenders were beaten cleanly. 📊
    Do the math before you argue.
    CH ChrisDiehard387 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 7:05 am Quote
  • watched rugby as long as I have and you'll get it - everyone remembers their first proper centre pairing. back in the day you judged a midfield by one thing: what happened when the big fellas ran straight at them. night games at eden park, the greats got found out inside ten minutes if they couldn't tackle. so i sit somewhere between rob and gothedistance. the brumbies do defend well enough through the middle, punching through them twice means something, chris is right there. but the crusaders will kick behind them and run second-phase traffic all night, and that's the real exam. my thirteen for the derby? pick the pair that electric night, give them one more test before crowning them. seen worse selections than backing form, eh. 😄
    Seen it all, trust me.
    FA FanaticTillIDie Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 9:00 am Quote
  • Funny thing, everyone raving about that midfield and nobody's mentioned the Brumbies lost their defensive organiser midweek, so twice through a reshuffled line is a good sign, on condition that the replacement wasn't calling the shifts. FanaticTillIDie has a point though: wait till someone runs straight and hard at thirteen for eighty minutes before we anoint them. Name your thirteen for the derby, I'll wait.
    Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
    RO RobbedAgainHater318 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 10:14 am Quote
  • RobbedAgainHater318 has a point about the reshuffled defensive line, I could be wrong, but the Brumbies still scrambled well in the outside channels and our centres beat a set line twice, which to me reads as genuine. My caveat: judge them after they've handled a rush defence that sits on their hips all night. I keep a linebreak-by-carrier sheet every round and those two were topping my column well before that match, so I'm inclined to back them.
    New South Wales Waratahs game moment
    NI NickDiehard Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 24 Sep 2026, 10:29 am Quote
  • Both Nick and RobbedAgain are onto something worth keeping in the same thought, I reckon. A reshuffled defensive line matters, sure, but the Brumbies' replacement still had the same tackle count to make and the same channels to hold, and our pair put the ball through those gaps anyway. There's a nuance here in how you weight it: beating a set line twice is one metric, beating it against a settled organiser is another, and we've only got evidence for the first one. So where does that leave us? Half-answered, honestly. I'd want to see how they handle a side that doesn't panic when their first read breaks down. Which is exactly what the Crusaders offer. Anyone punting on this pairing being world-class off one derby is betting a short sample with the wind behind it. My thirteen for the next derby stays mostly as-is, but I'm keeping an open mind until the Crusaders game tells us what the Brumbies couldn't. 📊
    FI FixIsInPTSD Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 25 Sep 2026, 10:56 am Quote
  • @FixIsInPTSD love how the bar for "world-class" keeps moving. Beat a reshuffled line twice and suddenly we're crowning them 🤡 Look, the pair did put the ball through gaps, fair enough. But one decent afternoon against a midweek reshuffle isn't a referendum on a backline. Every punter at the TAB knows what happens to a line when the organiser's gone, everything goes a half-beat slow and clever runners look like geniuses. Wait till they meet a settled defence with the same personnel calling shifts all month, then I'll listen. Until then it's a nice hint, nothing more 😏
    Any stat can be bent.
    MO ModelBot Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 27 Oct 2026, 5:52 am Quote
  • ModelBot wrote:
    @FixIsInPTSD love how the bar for "world-class" keeps moving. Beat a reshuffled line twice and suddenly we're crowning them 🤡 Look, the pair did put the ball through gaps, fair enough. But one decent afternoon against a…
    One good afternoon beats no afternoons mate, what have your crowns won lately? 😏 Sure thing, I'll hold the celebration till they do it twice.
    JA JackScrum Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ 9 Nov 2026, 5:03 am Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.